32. Camacho triple maduro robusto---Eville
Thanks for hosting Aaron - great selection of cigars guys!
Printable View
32. Camacho triple maduro robusto---Eville
Thanks for hosting Aaron - great selection of cigars guys!
Here's the final list (minus Craig's last selection)...everybody please check and make sure I have your selections right as this is what I'll be going off when I pack your boxes up. I'll also be adding DC#'s on this post as well as the first one.
1. EGQ 0309 0330 0000 7751 2457
17. Vegas Robaina Clasicos - Nov 99---Craig
33. Oliva MBIII Churchill---Eville
34. Partagas Serie D no. 4---Eville
36. Tabacos Baez Serie H Favoritos---Mizicke5273
3. AF Hemingway WOA Natty---Buzz
2. Tachy 0310 2640 0000 9955 9298
42. 2006 Don Carlos GOF Robusto Tubo---Logan 37
52. Zino Platinum Scepter ~ Grand Master Tubos---Badwhale
7. Tatuaje La Riqueza No. 3---slcraiders
16. Padron Magnum Maduro - Sep 07---Craig
29. La Aurora Preferido #2 Maduro---Paddy
3. Eville 0309 0330 0000 7751 2495
9. RASS (2006)---slcraiders
40. Padron Serie 1926 #2 ( Torpedo )---Mizicke5273
43. Ashton ESG 21 Year Robusto---Logan 37
47. Tat Verocu Red Tubo---EGQ
54. Padron Anniversary Maduro ~ Toro---Badwhale
4. Paddy
5. Davidoff Puro Dominicano Belicoso---Buzz
6. Winston Churchill #10---slcraiders
55. Mi Dominicana ~ Belicoso---Badwhale
8. Matasa 30th Anniversary Toro---slcraiders
4. PAM Exclusivo---Buzz
5. Logan37 0309 0330 0000 7751 2488
19. Bolivar Simones RE Canada - Nov 07---Craig
24. H. Upmann - Magnum 50 (ISOM)---TachyCoventry
51. Arturo Fuente Hemmingway ~ Between the Lines---Badwhale
37. Anejo #50---Mizicke5273
23. Drew Estates - Liga Privada No. 9 Parejo Oscuro---TachyCoventry
6. SLCRaiders 0309 0330 0000 7751 2334
60. Casa Fuente Belicoso---heftysmokes
27. Viaje Satori Double Perfecto---Paddy
49. Cohiba Puro Dominicana Coronas---EGQ
2. Tatuaje Verocu (red tubo)---Buzz
44. San Cristobal Monumento---Logan 37**
7. Ashauler 0309 0330 0000 7751 2464
56. Montecristo #2 ENE 10---heftysmokes
57. Partagas Serie P no. 2 SEP 09---heftysmokes
58. WOAM---heftysmokes
39. Ashton VSG Torpedo---Mizicke5273
48. Camacho 10th Anny---EGQ
8. Mizicke5273 0309 0330 0000 7751 2471
53. Liga Privada T52 ~ Flying Pig---Badwhale
41. LFD Factory Press II---Logan 37
14. Illusione CG4---ashauler
12. LFD Limitada IV---ashauler
13. Oliva V Belicoso---ashauler
9. Badwhale 0309 0330 0000 7751 2501
30. Paul Garmirian Gourmet Series Churchill---Paddy
10. Graycliff Chateau Grand Cru Pirate Piramide #2---slcraiders
11. El Triunfador lancero (original blend)---ashauler
46. Fuente Anejo Shark---EGQ
21. Alec Bradley - Magistri Maduro---TachyCoventry
10. Buzz 0310 2640 0000 9955 9304
18. Bolivar Belicosos Finos (cab) - Apr 07---Craig
20. Bolivar Short Bolivar RE Asia-Pacifico - Oct 08---Craig
59. Padron 1926 Serie #9 Maduro---heftysmokes
22. A. Fuente - Anejo The Shark---TachyCoventry
32. Camacho triple maduro robusto---Eville
11. Craig
26. Tatuaje Anarchy---Paddy
50. Opus Perfexcion X ---EGQ
45. 1 box(25 count) "It's a Girl" Corona (aka WOAM)---Logan 37
38. Opus X xXx---Mizicke5273
1. Liga Privada T52 Belicoso---Buzz
Mine!
15. PAM principe---ashauler
25. LFD - Chisel Natural---TachyCoventry
28. CAO Escaparate Columbia - Corona Gorda---Paddy
31. RP Olde World Reserve maduro toro---Eville
35. Chateau Fuente King T---Eville
Everybody, thanks for playing. It was my pleasure having all these beautiful cigars in my posession (if only temporarily). I hope everybody got a few sticks they wanted.
I know Rich was interested last year to see how people's picks finally ranked. So, FWIW:
(3) 30. Paul Garmirian Gourmet Series Churchill---Paddy
(5) 10. Graycliff Chateau Grand Cru Pirate Piramide #2---slcraiders
(7) 11. El Triunfador lancero (original blend)---ashauler
(11) 46. Fuente Anejo Shark---EGQ
(21) 21. Alec Bradley - Magistri Maduro---TachyCoventry
Will
Looks good to me.Quote:
Originally Posted by heftysmokes
Thank you for hosting, as it was a great time!:smiley20:
Hmmm, your last pick wasn't prime... interesting.Quote:
Originally Posted by badwhale
The first 3 cigars I got were in my top 10. :smiley20:
Quote:
Originally Posted by buzz
Paddy's...
(1) 5. Davidoff Puro Dominicano Belicoso---Buzz
(2) 6. Winston Churchill #10---slcraiders
(3) 55. Mi Dominicana ~ Belicoso---Badwhale
(5) 8. Matasa 30th Anniversary Toro---slcraiders
(11) 4. PAM Exclusivo---Buzz
...not too shabby there
1. Liga Privada T52 Belicoso---Buzz
Thanks for hosting the pass! My picks look good.
ETA: Pick ranking - I didn't have a set one all the way down, because I knew nothing about the majority of the smokes. However, being (second) last, I was pleasantly surprised that I was able to get some Opus. (I've only had one other Opus ever, and have never had any of my other picks, so that went well.)
Funny, I thought this one was easily the best of my puts, and it went last. (I'm talking of the particular boxes that I pulled the cigars from, not the brands or vitolas generally.) Two hours of smoking pleasure await you.Quote:
Originally Posted by TachyCoventry
The Magnums are good. If the AB went, that was next. Only reason it was down farther is I was trying to pick stuff I haven't had before.Quote:
Originally Posted by craig
Will
1) 53. Liga Privada T52 ~ Flying Pig---Badwhale
2) 41. LFD Factory Press II---Logan 37
3) 14. Illusione CG4---ashauler
4) 12. LFD Limitada IV---ashauler
18 or so) 13. Oliva V Belicoso---ashauler
Pretty good list.
I'm not quite brave enough to take on 9 inches yet.:smiley36:Quote:
Originally Posted by craig
2 - 9. RASS (2006)---slcraiders
5 - 40. Padron Serie 1926 #2 ( Torpedo )---Mizicke5273
6 - 43. Ashton ESG 21 Year Robusto---Logan 37
13 -47. Tat Verocu Red Tubo---EGQ
21 -54. Padron Anniversary Maduro ~ Toro---Badwhale
My list was pretty optimistic. I think most of my top 10 all went in the first 2 rounds. It's no 1,2,3 but I'm extremely satisfied. Thanks for hosting this Aaron!
Looks good to me Aaron.
I was able to pick my #1 and #3 choice. The other 3 were in my top 20. Plus that 2nd anejo Will picked for me was a nice surprise! Thanks again Aaron and thanks for everyone participating for the smooth run of the draft. (Except you Cody. Landfill my ass.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by logan37
Quote:
Originally Posted by buzz
Quote:
Originally Posted by TachyCoventry
so much fodder.....just don't think this can't follow you in to the PPPQuote:
Originally Posted by Eville
:smiley3:Quote:
Originally Posted by Eville
I'm happy with mine, here's how I had them ranked:
(1) 56. Montecristo #2 ENE 10---heftysmokes
(2) 57. Partagas Serie P no. 2 SEP 09---heftysmokes
(6) 58. WOAM---heftysmokes
(9) 39. Ashton VSG Torpedo---Mizicke5273
(19) 48. Camacho 10th Anny---EGQ
I can't say I haven't smoked them before....but, that's a good thing. :smiley20:
I am extremely pleased with my picks.:smiley20: Thanks again, Aaron. I did not pre-rank anything in advance, so I cannot share a breakdown.
Ok, these went out today...
EGQ
Badwhale
Ashauler
slcraiders
Eville
Logan
Mizicke
--Tachy, yours is on hold until I find a suitable box for the Padron; it's a hair long for the standard priority box
--Paddy's is on hold until he wants them sent along.
--Craig's is on hold because he's Canadian (that's not really why; I'm just going to do some creative packaging to make sure they get there clear).
--Buzz, I'm putting together a little something for your package, but I have to wait for the chili dog I had for lunch to pass so...
Just go ahead and cram Tachy's in there. He told me to tell you that, and also to not worry about being gentle. :smiley15:
:smiley3: That's two of those in this thread now!Quote:
Originally Posted by Eville
Ya, I might just cut three inches off the head of that, probably make for a nice morning quickie.
All these doors open and I'm fresh out of smart-ass replies. Shit.
Yeah, i'd say just the tip.
D*mn. Should've said something about re-using the box that I used.
Thanks again for hosting. Much appreciated.
Hefty - Thanks for hosting this draft it was a lot of fun and sorry for the delays that I caused near the end! As far as shipping please let me know what the difference in cost will be for the shipping and I'll cover the difference!
Play this game with my wife all the time. :smiley37:Quote:
Originally Posted by Eville
Ok, fellas, this is done on my end. Please post on here when your packages arrive. DC has been posted for everybody but Paddy and Craig (for obvious reasons).
It was fun; let's do it again soon!
Just brought em in, thanks again for putting this on:smiley20:
This just got cheesier. Package arrived today with a stow-away. Much appreciated Aaron. Thank you.
Safe and sound in megador.
Thanks, Aaron. Great draft.
Will
Just wanted to bring to everyone's attention. One of the sticks in my draftselection had a slight crack on the foot. Still smokable, but Aaron felt the urge to send an extra to "make up" for it. A+ brother in my book. Thank you.Quote:
Originally Posted by logan37
Aw, shucks.
Got mine today as well.
Got mine today as well......thank you, ya bastige. :smiley31:
Hefty - What was the difference in cost for the shipping so I can reimburse you!
I'll take a certified check for $.90.Quote:
Originally Posted by TachyCoventry
Just put a buck in a tip jar for me and we'll call it square.
Quote:
Originally Posted by heftysmokes
Really, just to be clear...do not send me ninety cents.
Sounds good, I'll give a dollar to a homeless sometime this week and say it's from you! If he says "God Bless You" like most of them do I'll let him know to direct it your way! Thanks!
Mine arrived -- looks like Aaron closely reviewed Will's how to ship cigars thread.
Sure hope that's not sarcasm.Quote:
Originally Posted by EGQ
Nope -- they were packed to perfection.Quote:
Originally Posted by heftysmokes
Quote:
Originally Posted by EGQ
Good deal. I actually received one package in the draft that had no packing material whatsoever around the cigars. 5 high end cigars, ziploc baggie, cardboard box.
I was shocked they arrived in good condition. Cigar gods must have been looking out.