Cigar Shopping Short List

Printable View

03-22-2006, 08:02 PM
Newfie

Cigar Shopping Short List
OK, I think I'm finally close to being at peace with my first humidor. Thanks to all who provided advice, links, etc. It was trying, but if anything, I learned a new level of patience I didn't know I had.

I am going to have a go at the Newbie Sampler once I have full confidence that my humi is all settled. I've heard nothing but good regarding this service from the great group of FOG's on the list.

After many hours doing searches, reading posts & reviews and looking through on-line shops, I've compiled a short list of what I want to go shopping for. In a perfect world, the shop I go to would have all in stock and would sell me a Mega-Sampler of 3 or 4 of each, but then again, I might have a period next week too.

Here's the list:
- Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
- Baccarat Luchadores
- Macanudo Baron de Rothschild
- National Brand Sun Grown Corona
- Oliva O Classic 6 - 50 (the biggest ring gauge on my list)
- Partagas #2 (in the event I'm in the mood for a stronger, heavier smoke)
- Punch Chateau M
- Romeo y Julieta Romeo's Court Tubo
There ya go. What I currently have, plus a bunch off the list above and what I score off the Newbie Sampler list, and I think I'll have a starter collection to be proud of.

I welcome all critiques of my list, good or bad, and as thick-skinned as I am, I'm even open to flaming if you so feel inclined. I'm also open to any more suggestions you feel should be on my list.

Thanks all for reading, and Da Newf is anxiously awaiting replies.
03-22-2006, 08:14 PM
kevin7

Nice start bro,remember you should try every cigar that sparks your interest as we all have different tastes . Only thing I would avoid at all costs is Acid and any other drew estate product IMHO
03-22-2006, 08:19 PM
Newfie

Thanks Kevin. I've read good and bad (more bad I think) about Acid. I guess you either love 'em or hate 'em
03-22-2006, 08:21 PM
kevin7

If you must try them then do so,hell I've smoked a few of them and won't give any herfer shit for smoking them. DO NOT put them with your other cigars or in a humidor or it will forever have a funky smell to it.
03-22-2006, 08:23 PM
kevin7

If you get the Oliva O classic then you should try the O maduro too. Very good cigar
03-22-2006, 08:24 PM
Newfie

Quote:

Originally Posted by kevin7

If you get the Oliva O classic then you should try the O maduro too. Very good cigar

Thanks, I'll add that to the list. I haven't read a whole lot about Olivia, but most has been good.
03-22-2006, 08:28 PM
slcraiders

Kevin7 is right about the Drew Estate smokes. If you must, go with cigars in their Natural line- (The Egg excluded). They are the closest resemblence to a good cigar that they make, IMO.
03-22-2006, 08:58 PM
bigpoppapuff

fonseca series f
vegas de fonseca

take the macanudo and throw it away...because friends don't let friends smoke macanudo's...
03-22-2006, 09:06 PM
Lopaka

Rocky Patel "Edge" and get rid of the Baccarat Luchadores.
03-22-2006, 09:12 PM
Newfie

Poppa:

OK, I'll add those, thanks.

Lopaka:

Aren't the Edge line a fairly heavy smoke and kind of out of line for a rookie?? I've read alot good about 'em, but to quote Rocky's Cigars:

Quote:

The Edge is for professional smokers only. This unrivaled experience fills the acclimatized palate with spicy constituents accenting it's full flavor. It will leave the seasoned smoker weak in the knees without a harsh finish.
03-22-2006, 09:17 PM
Newfie

Quote:

Originally Posted by slcraiders

snip... their Natural line- (The Egg excluded). They are the closest resemblence to a good cigar that they make, IMO.

Can't say I've seen much on those. You have a link??
03-22-2006, 09:19 PM
bigpoppapuff

hey lo....unless you've tried a baccarat recently,don't knock 'em...secretly,christian re-blended them two years ago...they're actually very tasty...and still mild...let him try 'em....
03-22-2006, 09:21 PM
bigpoppapuff

i would also suggest the oliva grand cameroon and grand maduro...and the oliva tenth anniversary...
03-22-2006, 09:38 PM
Lopaka

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigpoppapuff

hey lo....unless you've tried a baccarat recently,don't knock 'em...secretly,christian re-blended them two years ago...they're actually very tasty...and still mild...let him try 'em....

Ahhh cool...

The Baccarat are on my avoid like the plaugue list :smiley36:

The Edge is a very nice smoke. It was one of my first go to smokes when I first started. I like strong smokes, myself. I don't think it's that strong, however everyone has their different tastes.
03-22-2006, 09:43 PM
Newfie

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lopaka

Ahhh cool...

The Baccarat are on my avoid like the plaugue list :smiley36:

The Edge is a very nice smoke. It was one of my first go to smokes when I first started. I like strong smokes, myself. I don't think it's that strong, however everyone has their different tastes.

I'd try some on your say. Would you recommend the Corojo or the Sumatra??
03-22-2006, 09:49 PM
Lopaka

Torpedo Corojo is the one I went with. Let me know what you think :smiley20:
03-22-2006, 09:54 PM
Newfie

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lopaka

Torpedo Corojo is the one I went with. Let me know what you think :smiley20:

If I can find some, I will.

Thanks
03-22-2006, 10:26 PM
heftysmokes

The Edge is, IMHO, a fantastic smoke. In fact, it was the first cigar I tried that made me think, "Damn, that's what all the fuss is about!"

I also agree with Big Poppa's take on the Baccarat; I think it's a good line, especially for the price.
03-23-2006, 05:58 AM
prophetic_joe

Quote:

Originally Posted by Newfie

Aren't the Edge line a fairly heavy smoke and kind of out of line for a rookie?? I've read alot good about 'em, but to quote Rocky's Cigars:

Nothing is out of line for a rookie. Try everything that strikes your interest. I smoked cigars maybe 3 or 4 times in 3 years, always liked it but was never really hooked on the hobby. I was out golfing with my friend last summer and we had some La Gloria Cubana Serie R #5, that was the cigar that reeled me in. I find out later that it's on the medium to strong side of things. So hey you may like something a little stronger too.

welcome to CS. :smiley37:
03-24-2006, 03:22 AM
WOXOF

You're on the right track. Nice little list. I see Cbid in your future. As a former victim of the Newb sampler thread, I'll tell you it is definitely worth it. Try a good variety of cigars. I'm a newbie and I've found that I really like the medium strength maduros. Give the Sancho Panza double maduro a try. Great smoke for the price too.

On a side note... I picked up some Baccarat Luchadores to give out at poker games to guys who don't normally smoke. I didn't plan on smoking them myself, but after BPP's comment I may have to give one a shot. :smiley41:
03-24-2006, 10:06 AM
basil

CBid is Satan. My parents, friends, and a neighborhood militia had to kidnap and de-program me, over a 6 month period. Then I had to have some hardware installed that would cause me to receive a strong electrical shock when I clicked my mouse on any CBid link. I was shocked twice writing this post.

heh - nice list newfie. I agree w/BPP on the macs. K7 is deadon with the Oliva maduros - very nice smoke. The RPs are good. You might want to see about Gran Habano - the red label is my preference - from there they get milder (two more). And, you cannot go wrong with the El Rey de Mundo oscuro - any length really, though I prefer robusto.
03-24-2006, 12:48 PM
Newfie

Thanks Basil and WOXOF.

No worries about me & C-Bid. As enticing as the pricing and selection is, if I buy on-line from anywhere and I get tagged for tobacco duties and taxes, I may as well just go to a local B&M and buy something from ISOM. They really nail us here in the frozen north with smoke taxes.

Only think now is my shopping list has more than doubled!! Now if I could only get work to send me to Richmond, or Joisey, or Baton Rouge (we have offices and plants all over) I could really do some serious shopping!!!

PS:

I hate friggin' borders and taxes.
03-25-2006, 06:53 PM
The Master

Newfie, here is a list of cigars by country that I think you would enjoy. They are all reasonably priced cigars when bought by the box and from the right source. You can also by all of these in some form of 5 packs or samplers I believe.

Dominican Republic:

Arturo Fuente 858 in Natural ( cameroon wrapper) and Maduro ( Conneticutt Broad Leaf)

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature

Arturo Fuente Don Carlos robusto

Nicaragua:

Padron 3000 or Ambassador in maduro

Joya De Nicaragua Antano churchill

Tatuaje Especiales

Honduras:

El Rey Del Mundo Rectangulars in maduro and Flor De Llaneza in natural

Jr Ultimate Cetros and Toros in double maduro
03-25-2006, 08:05 PM
Newfie

Thanks Master. Appreciate the suggestions.
03-25-2006, 09:11 PM
BunkyX

Your list and all the suggested additions look pretty good. I also agree that you should try as many different brands and sizes as a comparison. One persons dog rocket is anothers favorite smoke. I also agree that the infused cigars such as Acid should be avoided but who knows you may like them. Read what these guys say about cigars and you will get some good clues as to good smokes. Their post about Padrons got me to try them and now I smoke a 3000 every day with my first cup of coffee. Great way to start off the day with a cup of real coffee (not the canned stuff but whole bean) and a Padron. Although these guys may not think alot of them I also smoke a Roly #2 Maduro daily and a Fuente Curly Head.
I might suggest you try Montecristo Platinum, CAO Criollo, Trinidad, and Cuesta Rey if they are not already on your list.:smiley16: