MEGA Review: Camacho Corojo 10th Anniversary Torpedo

https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-r...g/s540/mr5.png
https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-m...s478/irene.jpg

About the cigar:
Brand:	Camacho	Color:	Natural
Name:	10th Anniversary	Wrapper:	Honduras
Country:	Honduras	Binder:	Honduras
Type:	Torpedo	Filler:	Honduras
Size:	6'' x 54	Price:	$ 10.14
Strength:	Medium-Full	Website:	www.camachocigars.com

---

Information from Tex Cigars:

The Camacho 10th Anniversary cigar was designed to celebrate the 10th year of the making of a truly unique and beautiful corojo wrapper. All of the cigars in this line are box-pressed to perfection and are aged to make them extra creamy and smooth. These cigars are considered to be medium to full-bodied smokes.

---

General:	Experience	Date Smoked	Where Smoked	Duration	Smoked
badwhale	Amateur	5/2	Basement	1.25 hours	Most of it
buzz	Newbie	5/5	Backyard	1.5 hours	Most of it
craig	Newbie	5/4	Upstairs	1.75 hours	Nubbed it
FightingFish	Newbie	5/6	Den	1 hour	Most of it
heftysmokes	Amateur	5/5	Patio	1 hour	Half of it
Irish79	Newbie	5/5	Deck	1 hour	Most of it
kevin7	Been around	5/6	Patio	1 hour	Nubbed it
logan37	Amateur	5/4	Front porch	1.5 hours	Most of it
Mangyrat	Amateur	5/6	Out in my shop	1 hour	Most of it
Mizicke5273	Amateur	5/4	Back deck	1.75 hours	Most of it
mrtr33	Newbie	5/5	Backyard	1 hour	Nubbed it
prophetic_joe	Amateur	5/3	Cigar room	45 minutes	Half of it
TheGreekTitan	Newbie	5/3	My backyard	1.25 hours	Nubbed it
VancouverMark	Newbie	4/30	Work	1.25 hours	Most of it

---

Other Info:	Food	Drink	Entertainment
badwhale	N/A	Sierra Nevada ~ Torpedo	SRV; Johnny Winter
buzz	N/A	Pyramid Hefeweizen	The moon
craig	N/A	Cider	'The Necktie' (animated short)
FightingFish	Grilled tri-tip	Coke	N/A
heftysmokes	N/A	Sam Adams Alpine Spring	Songza
Irish79	Steak & baked potato	Water	Radio 104.5
kevin7	N/A	Diet Mt. Dew Code Red	N/A
logan37	N/A	Sam Adams Summer Ale	Pandora
Mangyrat	N/A	Ice water	N/A
Mizicke5273	N/A	Lagavulin and a Diet Coke	Dungeons & Dragons
prophetic_joe	MadeRites	Captain and Coke	N/A
TheGreekTitan	N/A	Stella Artois	Running water and chirping birds
VancouverMark	N/A	Coffee	N/A

---

Miscellaneous:
Quote: Originally Posted by badwhale 6x48 torp. Slight crack at head, but nothing the Xikar won't take care of. Solid colorado shade wrapper with nice construction. Slight sweet tobacco scent.	Quote: Originally Posted by buzz Watching the moon rise.
Quote: Originally Posted by craig 'The necktie' (animated short) and 'Cry of the wild' (classic would documentary) at nfb.ca	Quote: Originally Posted by heftysmokes Waiting for this supposed big ass moon to come out from behind the clouds.
Quote: Originally Posted by logan37 It's not raining.	Quote: Originally Posted by Mangyrat Watching the weeds I call a lawn grow.
Quote: Originally Posted by Mizicke5273 This cigar was quite veiny. The first D&D movie always reminds me of the Legend of Dragoon for Playstation. I always enjoy both, and this cigar was a great accompaniment to the movie!	Quote: Originally Posted by mrtr33 I sat in a chair.
Quote: Originally Posted by TheGreekTitan For some reason we started talking about Irene first when we got the packages. I have been looking forward to this one for a while.

---

Appearance:	Poor	Fair	Good	Outstanding	Perfect
badwhale				X
buzz			X
craig			X
FightingFish		X
heftysmokes				X
Irish79			X
kevin7				X
logan37					X
Mangyrat			X
Mizicke5273			X
mrtr33			X
prophetic_joe			X
TheGreekTitan			X
VancouverMark			X

---

Construction:	Poor	Fair	Good	Outstanding	Perfect
badwhale				X
buzz			X
craig			X
FightingFish			X
heftysmokes			X
Irish79			X
kevin7			X
logan37				X
Mangyrat			X
Mizicke5273				X
mrtr33			X
prophetic_joe			X
TheGreekTitan			X
VancouverMark			X

---

Burn:	Very Uneven	Uneven	Even	Perfect
badwhale			X
buzz			X
craig			X
FightingFish		X
heftysmokes			X
Irish79			X
kevin7		X
logan37				X
Mangyrat			X
Mizicke5273		X
mrtr33			X
prophetic_joe		X
TheGreekTitan			X
VancouverMark			X

---

Draw:	Too Easy	Easy	Perfect	Tight	Too Tight
badwhale		X
buzz			X
craig	X
FightingFish		X
heftysmokes		X
Irish79		X
kevin7			X
logan37		X
Mangyrat		X
Mizicke5273			X
mrtr33	X
prophetic_joe		X
TheGreekTitan	X
VancouverMark		X

---

Ash Color:	Black	Dark Gray	Gray	Light Gray	White
badwhale			X
buzz				X
craig				X
FightingFish				X
heftysmokes			X
Irish79			X
kevin7				X
logan37				X
Mangyrat			X
Mizicke5273				X
mrtr33		X
prophetic_joe				X
TheGreekTitan			X
VancouverMark			X

---

Ash Structure:	Flaky	Typical	Solid
badwhale		X
buzz		X
craig		X
FightingFish		X
heftysmokes		X
Irish79	X
kevin7		X
logan37		X
Mangyrat		X
Mizicke5273	X
mrtr33		X
prophetic_joe		X
TheGreekTitan		X
VancouverMark		X

---

Ash Length:	< 1 inch	1 inch	1-1/2 inch	2 inch	> 2 inch
badwhale			X
buzz			X
craig			X
FightingFish	X
heftysmokes	X
Irish79	X
kevin7		X
logan37		X
Mangyrat		X
Mizicke5273		X
mrtr33		X
prophetic_joe		X
TheGreekTitan		X
VancouverMark					X

---

Aroma:	Horrid	Poor	Fair	Good	Great
badwhale					X
buzz					X
craig			X
FightingFish			X
heftysmokes				X
Irish79				X
kevin7				X
logan37					X
Mangyrat				X
Mizicke5273					X
mrtr33					X
prophetic_joe			X
TheGreekTitan				X
VancouverMark				X

---

Strength:	Mild	Mild-Med	Medium	Med-Full	Full
badwhale			X
buzz		X
craig				X
FightingFish			X
heftysmokes		X
Irish79			X
kevin7				X
logan37			X
Mangyrat				X
Mizicke5273				X
mrtr33		X
prophetic_joe			X
TheGreekTitan			X
VancouverMark			X

---

Prelight Taste:
Quote: Originally Posted by badwhale Light tobacco flavor on cut prelight taste.	Quote: Originally Posted by buzz I forgot to check because I was too worried about cutting the head without completely unraveling this delicate girl of a cigar.
Quote: Originally Posted by Irish79 The cap was busted with a tear running an inch down the side of the cigar. Pleasant prelight aroma. Cut & lit easily.	Quote: Originally Posted by kevin7 Woody.
Quote: Originally Posted by logan37 Slightly sweet and earthy.	Quote: Originally Posted by Mangyrat It tasted like a cigar.
Quote: Originally Posted by Mizicke5273 Very leathery with a bit of earthiness.	Quote: Originally Posted by mrtr33 I didn't notice anything. It smells like all the other Grape Owls in my humidor.
Quote: Originally Posted by prophetic_joe I didn't detect much flavor on the pre-light on this one.	Quote: Originally Posted by TheGreekTitan Good tobacco flavor with a little bit of sweetness. Very airy draw.
Quote: Originally Posted by VancouverMark Woodsy and earthy. Not a lot of pre-light taste.

---

Taste 1st Third:
Quote: Originally Posted by badwhale Oily and bitter out the gate, but a woodsy / earthy undertone on slow exhale. A little sweet tobacco.	Quote: Originally Posted by buzz Nice. Sweet cedar wood taste with a little spice, tons of smoke, perfect burn, tight ash, fantastic draw (on the loose side). Wrapper is super delicate though which is pretty annoying.
Quote: Originally Posted by craig A lightly-packed cigar, so a very slow draw is needed. Nice pure black tobacco taste - I don't think this is a Franken-cigar.	Quote: Originally Posted by FightingFish Woodsy and sweet.
Quote: Originally Posted by Irish79 Good draw = plenty of smoke. Some initial spice that seemed to fade away the more I smoked.	Quote: Originally Posted by kevin7 Leathery and peppery.
Quote: Originally Posted by logan37 Had as nice mild spice on the finish. Tasted of earthy tobacco. Slightly sweet on the draw.	Quote: Originally Posted by Mangyrat Tobacco and about 1 inch in spice/pepper.
Quote: Originally Posted by Mizicke5273 Voluptuous amounts of smoke! Each draw starts off with a nice leathery taste, which is slightly creamy, and finishes off with a nice spice hit on the throat.	Quote: Originally Posted by mrtr33 This was one of the rare cigars I've smoked where I can tell some flavor within the first 5-10 puffs or so. It's a very pleasant, yet distinctive 'tobacco' taste - not too lingering, but not overwhelming, either. Right at the end of the first third, I'm getting some heavy spice.
Quote: Originally Posted by prophetic_joe Started off very mild seeming to me. I wasn't picking up a whole lot of flavor which was disappointing. The cigar turned around about halfway through the 3rd though and became a little more spicy with a hint of sweet. It wasn't overly smooth and changed from what I had thought was a milder cigar into a medium body. I had a nasty crack in the cap of this one so I was kind of fighting that and the burn was a bit more uneven than I like but overall the cigar at this point was not bad.	Quote: Originally Posted by TheGreekTitan Good flavor, unfortunately no spice though. Figures I drink water with the AVO and bust out the Stella for Irene.
Quote: Originally Posted by VancouverMark Lot's of rich thick smoke. Mainly earthy and woody tones. Very nice so far.

---

Taste 2nd Third:
Quote: Originally Posted by badwhale Oily is still there, but mellowed. Woodsy and creamy sweet tobacco. Damn, these are nice. Medium body, full flavor.	Quote: Originally Posted by buzz Spice went away as expected, still has that woody sweetness which is great. Wrapper is ticking me off. The moon doesn't look any bigger than it normally does...
Quote: Originally Posted by craig Just wonderful. Nicely-fermented/aged tobacco. The wrapper is a bit fragile.	Quote: Originally Posted by FightingFish Woodsy and sweet.
Quote: Originally Posted by heftysmokes Had to can this one. Kid woke up with a bad dream. Dad duty calls.	Quote: Originally Posted by Irish79 I ended up with visitors and had to abandon the smoke for a bit, resulting in a relight. After that the burn was uneven with some tunneling.
Quote: Originally Posted by kevin7 Leathery still and a very tiny sweet taste.	Quote: Originally Posted by logan37 Spice went way down. But flavor was still pretty good. Same as the first but slightly sweeter.
Quote: Originally Posted by Mangyrat More of the same.	Quote: Originally Posted by Mizicke5273 A nice earthy taste has developed to replace the leather and spice. Though the taste has become slightly more creamier now. Still copious amounts of thick smoke pouring out. I love it!
Quote: Originally Posted by mrtr33 Spice has faded a bit. The cigar has changed, and it seems like it's getting sweet. Incredibly smooth - no harshness at all. The cigar itself gives when I squeeze it, which knocks some construction points off for me, and the burn is only kind of even, but not to the point where I have to fix it. It's smoking like a mess, but the taste is awesome. I'm puffing like a chimney at this point, not wanting to give this part of the cigar up.	Quote: Originally Posted by prophetic_joe The cap during this section of the cigar took a real turn for the worse, it looked like i was one of those guys who just chews the smoke. The burn is still a bit uneven and the cigar is requiring more attention than any of the previous MR5 ladies. I don't like my girls needy. The cigar has gotten a bit more spicy and for me the sweetness has gone away to be replaced by a harsh taste that I really don't care for. I am not hating the cigar at this point but it is certainly not my favorite.
Quote: Originally Posted by TheGreekTitan Pretty much the same as the 1st. A little stronger with a retro-hale. Nothing out of this world, but a good clean smoke.	Quote: Originally Posted by VancouverMark Developing a nice oily wood and leather taste. Very smooth and earthy.

---

Taste 3rd Third:
Quote: Originally Posted by badwhale More of the same deliciousness. Woodsy / earthy sweet, creamy tobacco with some background oily bitterness for balance.	Quote: Originally Posted by buzz Started to got hot and harsh, wrapper is flailing around like an orangutan. I probably smoked this last third too fast.
Quote: Originally Posted by craig Cops amounts of smoke, but with lots of flavor. Leather aftertaste.	Quote: Originally Posted by kevin7 Strong leather like my old Levis belt minus the sweat LOL.
Quote: Originally Posted by logan37 Spice picked up again in the 3rd. More of a bite to it then there was earlier. Hints of leather came out.	Quote: Originally Posted by Mangyrat Not much changed still a nice cigar.
Quote: Originally Posted by Mizicke5273 The spice returned in the final third and became the dominate taste. Though once there was less than 3/4 in. left, a bit of harshness developed.	Quote: Originally Posted by mrtr33 Spice is back - though not as prevalent. Loooooong finish. Seemed like this part of the cigar took just as long as the first two thirds combined. The binding is coming apart, I'm afraid that if I put the cigar down at this point, it will completely explode, but it's very good.
Quote: Originally Posted by prophetic_joe The taste of Irene to me has gotten pretty harsh, the spice I was enjoying has taken a backseat and now the lady has turned into something I don't want to have any longer of a relationship with, I find I am missing Halle quite a bit at this point. It is time unfortunately to break it off with Irene, we had a few good times but unfortunately her neediness and harsh attitude has gotten worse and I don't believe counseling will help us.	Quote: Originally Posted by TheGreekTitan More of the same. I like it, but very one dimensional.
Quote: Originally Posted by VancouverMark Great cigar. Fairly consistent from start to finish with lot's of wood, peat, and earth. Wish I had a nice single malt to go with this!

---

Grading:	1st Third	2nd Third	3rd Third	Overall
badwhale	A	A	A	A
buzz	A	B	C	B
craig	A	A	A	A
FightingFish	B+	B	B	B
heftysmokes	B+	B	-	B
kevin7	B+	B+	-	B+
logan37	A-	B	A	A-
Mangyrat	A-	A-	A-	A-
Mizicke5273	A	A	B+	A
mrtr33	A	A	A	A
prophetic_joe	B	C	D	C
TheGreekTitan	B	B	B	B
VancouverMark	A-	A-	A	A
Average	A-	B+	B+	B+

---

Thoughts:	Smoke Again	Buy a Box	Recommend
badwhale	Definitely	Yes	Definitely
buzz	Yes	Yes	Yes
craig	Definitely	Yes	Definitely
FightingFish	Maybe	Probably not	Maybe
heftysmokes	Yes	Probably not	Maybe
kevin7	Yes	Maybe	Yes
logan37	Yes	Maybe	Yes
Mangyrat	Yes	Maybe	Yes
Mizicke5273	Definitely	Yes	Yes
mrtr33	Yes	Maybe	Yes
prophetic_joe	Probably not	Definitely not	Probably not
TheGreekTitan	Yes	Probably not	Maybe
VancouverMark	Definitely	Yes	Definitely

---

Last Words:
Quote: Originally Posted by badwhale 10th anny.	Quote: Originally Posted by buzz I am going to buy a box of the rothschilds. This is a tasty cigar and worth dealing with the wrapper issues.
Quote: Originally Posted by craig Finally, my kind of cigar.	Quote: Originally Posted by heftysmokes Wish I could have finished this cigar. I honestly have no idea what it it (which makes me three for three!)
Quote: Originally Posted by kevin7 Pretty nice cigar, no JdN Antano but still a pretty powerful cigar.	Quote: Originally Posted by logan37 I think this is a Camacho 10th Anniversary. But I may have just shot myself in the foot.
Quote: Originally Posted by Mangyrat To me this was a good every day cigar.	Quote: Originally Posted by Mizicke5273 This cigar really hit the spot and the Lagavulin went phenomenally with it! Really, another awesome cigar? Two in a row? I really hope I enjoy the final.....
Quote: Originally Posted by mrtr33 Overall, I thought this was really good. I normally don't like ring gauges this large, and constructurally, I thought this cigar was a mess. But the taste was awesome, I loved the flavor profile throughout.	Quote: Originally Posted by prophetic_joe While I didn't have a good relationship with Irene I am still possibly willing, eventually, to give her another try however for now I think we need time apart.
Quote: Originally Posted by TheGreekTitan I liked Irene, but a bit of a one trick pony. Maybe I cut too much off the cap, the airy draw really detracted from the experience. That said, I would definitely give this stick another smoke given the opportunity.

---

Pictures:

https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-P...prelight01.jpg


https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-w...prelight02.jpg


https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-g...prelight03.jpg


https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-t...prelight04.jpg


https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-q...s576/1st01.jpg


https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-N...s800/1st02.jpg


https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-4...s576/1st03.jpg


https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-w...s800/1st04.jpg


https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-m...s800/1st05.jpg


https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-W...s640/1st06.jpg

Pictures (continued):

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-3...s640/ash01.jpg


https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-G...s800/2nd02.jpg


https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-_...s800/2nd03.jpg


https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-A...s640/2nd04.jpg


https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-m...s800/2nd01.jpg


https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-O...s800/3rd01.jpg


https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-Q...s800/3rd02.jpg


https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-n...s576/3rd03.jpg


https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-s...s640/3rd04.jpg


https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-w...s800/nub01.jpg


https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-c...s800/nub02.jpg

Editor's Note:


These cigars were purchased from Tex Cigars. We picked them up for $212.94 with free shipping (box of 21). Atlantic Cigar has one box of these left for $172.95 but they didn't have that deal when we purchased the MR5 cigars (sorry guys). The cigars came nicely packaged, in that annoying pyramid-ish shaped Camacho box that doesn't fit in your coolidor easily. I didn't see any damage to the cigars but getting the cello and bands off without damaging the wrapper was an absolute royal pain. I ended up using an X-acto knife to cut a slit in the cello to avoid cracking the head of the cigar, it took me 3 times as long to get these finicky cigars ready for shipping than it did all the other ones.

https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-0...00/camacho.jpg

Blowholes:	Brand	Country	Price	Points
badwhale	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2048
craig	- voted off -			0
FightingFish	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2048
kevin7	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2048
Paddy	- voted off -			0
TheGreekTitan	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2048
VancouverMark	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2048
Total:				10,240

---

Whiny Bitches:	Brand	Country	Price	Points
heftysmokes	601	Dominican Republic	$8.12	1298
Irish79	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2548
logan37	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2548
Mangyrat	Perdomo	Nicaragua	$6.47	1133
Mizicke5273	Camacho	Honduras	$11.55	2109
mrtr33	Montecristo	Dominican Republic	$16.15	399
prophetic_joe	Camacho	Honduras	$8.12	2048
Total:				12,083

---

Standings:	Brands Correct	Countries Correct	Total $ Off	Total Points
Irish79	3	2	$3.56	9458
logan37	3	4	$2.12	8288
TheGreekTitan	2	3	$4.84	7256
Mizicke5273	2	3	$2.69	6481
heftysmokes	2	2	$6.39	6361
VancouverMark	2	2	$5.51	5949
kevin7	2	3	$8.60	5890
badwhale	2	3	$9.10	5840
craig	2	2	$7.17	5783
prophetic_joe	2	2	$6.95	5298
FightingFish	2	3	$16.42	4601
Mangyrat	1	1	$11.82	4568
mrtr33	1	1	$9.91	4259
Paddy	0	0	$34.35	1565

---

Irish79 is still in the lead, the Blowholes figured out the exact identity of Irene but missed her price by a couple bucks. The additional Side Challenge points gave the Whiny Bitches the win this round. Good luck with the final round guys! Remember, the top 4 spots from the winning team and the top 3 spots from the losing team will receive prize packs.

---

Bet you thought you had that one in the bag, didn't cha blowies.