Smoked one last night. Had some problems with it, seemed to have a slight crack or hole near were I cut it. Maybe they had dried out a bit too much on the journey here. Still it was an excellent smoke. The taste was complex throughout. The ash was beautiful and straight. The prelight aroma and construction were flawless. I'd give it a 89 rating due to the crack/hole. The next one should be better once they've sat in my coolidor for a week or two.