Online: I'd have to say waiting for them to ship and not knowing what you might really be getting. The possibility of fakes or damaged goods from poor packing or crappy parcel handlers. I'd definitely have to say bargain hunting is the best since everything is a click away and no shipping for out of state retailers.
B&M: Looking through large selection of cigars gets overwhelming. I've caught myself daydreaming in a humidor for over 30 minutes about all the possibilities. CA tax sucks and usually a lot of B&Ms charge an arm and a leg. Best part about B&Ms are instant gratification. You buy it and walk out with it in your hand and possibly smoke it in their non-membership lounge.
Bookmarks