I'd have to say my top cigars are:

Ashton VSG Torpedo
Padron 1964 Anniversary
Tatuaje Havana VI (Verocu No. 2)
AF Hemingway (WOAM is my fav)
Graycliff (When they're cheap)
La Flor Dominicana (Lots of Ligero)
Camacho (Any will do)
Oliva and Nubs
Coronado
AF Anejo (Shark)

I'd probably say I would go out of my way to my hands on these and savor them to the last nub, but there are a lot I haven't tried enough of to get my head wrapped around them. Notable ones are probably the DC Maximus series, Ashton ESG, LX2 line, Opus X and Illusiones. I'm sure there are more but there are just so many good cigars out there