i think it was some cuban hoya cigar that got a 99. the rocky patel decades got a 95.

i have to agree though that the CA ratings dont mean much. i was talking to a guy who used to go purchase the cigars for the CA guys. for their blind smokes, he would take the rings off, so that they dont know what they are smoking. trouble is, he said these guys smoke so much that they always knew exactly what they were smoking even though there was no ring. so their "blind" cigar smokes really arent totally "blind" and because of that they are probably at least a little biased. and yea, it seems to me that the ratings are rigged. certain companies who advertise with them seem to get better treatment when it comes to reviews. if you ask me, the CA ratings are a sham.