Budget Box Pass

[CAJUNBLAZE]

Ok guys here we go...

Maduro tray:
Take: #3 Padron Executive, $5.87 - Put: #29 La Riqueza No. 2, $7.25(pd)
Take: #6 Oliva O M Torp, $5.59 - Put: #30 Cabaiguan Guapo RX, $ 7.12

That should make it a Padron and Tat tray!

Triple corta tray:
Take: #10 Quintero Breva, $2.40 - Put #31 Cuaba Divinos 2008, $3.81
Take: #13 Por Larrañaga Panatela, $2.49 - Put #32 Punch Petit Punch 2007, $4.00(pd)

Long Stick tray:
Take: #16 Cohiba EL 06 Pyramid, $25.99 - Put #33 God of Fire Carlito Piramide '05, $28.98
Take: #17 Partagás Presidente, $7.05 - Put #34 Vegas Robaina Unicos 2008, $7.60

Long-Filler tray:
Take #22 Bolivar Short Bolivar RE A/P, $11.84 - Put #35 Romeo Y Julieta EL 2007, $12.03
Take #24 Bolivar Belicoso Fino, $ 7.86 - Put #36 Cohiba Maduro 5 Secreto 2008, $7.87

Those marked pd are ones I paid less then the going rate.
Thanks Craig for letting me join!

Rich

[craig]

Ok guys here we go...

Maduro tray:
Take: #3 Padron Executive, $5.87 - Put: #29 La Riqueza No. 2, $7.25(pd)
Take: #6 Oliva O M Torp, $5.59 - Put: #30 Cabaiguan Guapo RX, $ 7.12

That should make it a Padron and Tat tray!

Triple corta tray:
Take: #10 Quintero Breva, $2.40 - Put #31 Cuaba Divinos 2008, $3.81
Take: #13 Por Larrañaga Panatela, $2.49 - Put #32 Punch Petit Punch 2007, $4.00(pd)

Long Stick tray:
Take: #16 Cohiba EL 06 Pyramid, $25.99 - Put #33 God of Fire Carlito Piramide '05, $28.98
Take: #17 Partagás Presidente, $7.05 - Put #34 Vegas Robaina Unicos 2008, $7.60

Long-Filler tray:
Take #22 Bolivar Short Bolivar RE A/P, $11.84 - Put #35 Romeo Y Julieta EL 2007, $12.03
Take #24 Bolivar Belicoso Fino, $ 7.86 - Put #36 Cohiba Maduro 5 Secreto 2008, $7.87

Those marked pd are ones I paid less then the going rate.
Thanks Craig for letting me join!

Rich

Thanks for being first Rich!

Very nice That last take/put looks inspired - and the GoF - I didn't expect that . One minor point - month of box date is nice if available.

edit: that looked like a lot for the Short Boli. Use $10.95US as my purchase price. Feel free to change your put(s).

For first-timers, class is now in session . I said there will be math .

Who agrees, who disagrees Please show your work .

Check for what cigars have already been looked at, pick one or two different puts/takes, post which ones you will look at, and edit calcs into your post before Tuesday.

Please note that this is not about adjusting for nickel or dime differences, but the pass is about learning via explaining differences .

[CAJUNBLAZE]

The short Boli trade is ok with me. I would rather error on the pass side then my side!

Can you change a trade in a tray once your puts and takes are posted? I am thinking of changing one if allowed.

Rich

[EGQ]

I agree with the math on the Oliva O M Torp -- assuming it is the 6" Torp II, which it looks to be based on the pic. Seven retailers on cigarcyclopedia, all within $20, none excluded.

115.20
98.95
101.90
117.95
118.99
111.95
117.75
______
782.69/7 = 111.8129/20 = $5.59

Also agree with the math on the Cabaiguan Guapo Rx -- two retailers within .04 of eachother.

170.99
170.95
______
170.97/24 = $7.12

[craig]

I agree with the math on the Oliva O M Torp -- assuming it is the 6" Torp II, which it looks to be based on the pic. Seven retailers on cigarcyclopedia, all within $20, none excluded.

115.20
98.95
101.90
117.95
118.99
111.95
117.75
______
782.69/7 = 111.8129/20 = $5.59

Also agree with the math on the Cabaiguan Guapo Rx -- two retailers within .04 of eachother.

170.99
170.95
______
170.97/24 = $7.12

I'm pretty sure that it is the 6" x 52. The O Mad was the last of a box, and is over a year old and very ready-to-smoke.

Pass!

While I'm here, I just want to assure the first-timers that over-puts are not expected in a beginner pass. First-timers should aim to be close in value. Experienced folks can do whatever they want .

[ashauler]

I'm pretty sure that it is the 6" x 52. The O Mad was the last of a box, and is over a year old and very ready-to-smoke.

Pass!

While I'm here, I just want to assure the first-timers that over-puts are not expected in a beginner pass. First-timers should aim to be close in value. Experienced folks can do whatever they want .

The beginning values of the pass appear to be well distributed and reasonable, it should be the objective of the pass participants to keep it that way while exchanging sticks. The p/t's below significantly increase the value of the sticks exchanged.....more that $1/stick. If this continues throughout the pass, the sticks needing to be exchanged down the line could get out of reach for some.

Take 3 ~ Worth:$5.87 Put 29 ~ Worth: $8.44
Take 6 ~ Worth:$5.64 Put 30 ~ Worth: $7.12
Take 10 ~ Worth:$2.40 Put 31 ~ Worth: $4.22
Take 13 ~ Worth:$2.49 Put 32 ~ Worth: $4.38
Take 22 ~ Worth:$11.81 Put 35 ~ Worth: $17.00

[prophetic_joe]

The beginning values of the pass appear to be well distributed and reasonable, it should be the objective of the pass participants to keep it that way while exchanging sticks. The p/t's below significantly increase the value of the sticks exchanged.....more that $1/stick. If this continues throughout the pass, the sticks needing to be exchanged down the line could get out of reach for some.

Take 3 ~ Worth:$5.87 Put 29 ~ Worth: $8.44
Take 6 ~ Worth:$5.64 Put 30 ~ Worth: $7.12
Take 10 ~ Worth:$2.40 Put 31 ~ Worth: $4.22
Take 13 ~ Worth:$2.49 Put 32 ~ Worth: $4.38
Take 22 ~ Worth:$11.81 Put 35 ~ Worth: $17.00

The man has a point. Considering this is a pass with a lot of new members we do need to try to keep the values a lot closer to what the original sticks were. I know when I was a new member on CP and would want to get involved in a pass I'd look at the list and realize I had nothing to really offer. It's not going to be a good feeling for that new guy to get that pass and see that he really can't swap out with more than a couple of cigars but still have to fork over the money to ship it to the next guy. Not going to be fun considering he didn't really get to play much.

[craig]

The beginning values of the pass appear to be well distributed and reasonable, it should be the objective of the pass participants to keep it that way while exchanging sticks. The p/t's below significantly increase the value of the sticks exchanged.....more that $1/stick. If this continues throughout the pass, the sticks needing to be exchanged down the line could get out of reach for some.

Take 3 ~ Worth:$5.87 Put 29 ~ Worth: $8.44
Take 6 ~ Worth:$5.64 Put 30 ~ Worth: $7.12
Take 10 ~ Worth:$2.40 Put 31 ~ Worth: $4.22
Take 13 ~ Worth:$2.49 Put 32 ~ Worth: $4.38
Take 22 ~ Worth:$11.81 Put 35 ~ Worth: $17.00

Those are Will's calcs. Rich's are closer, I have 35 at a couple dollars more than the Short Boli, not $5.

Rich, you put up your list first, so you don't have adjust your lower-end p/t. If you want to change them, then please go ahead, of course. Going first always means that you get the most discussion .

Going forward from Rich, please keep it closer on the under-$10 sticks. When I built the pass, I was looking for a mix of $1-$3 sticks, $3-$6, $6-$12, and over $12 sticks. Let's try and keep it that way.

[craig]

The short Boli trade is ok with me. I would rather error on the pass side then my side!

Can you change a trade in a tray once your puts and takes are posted? I am thinking of changing one if allowed.

Rich

Yup, you can change. You can post up changes once you see the cigars, too. Sometimes a cigar just calls out to you when you see it .

[badwhale]

Here's my analysis:

Take 3 ~ Worth:$5.87 Put 29 ~ Worth: $8.44
Take 6 ~ Worth:$5.64 Put 30 ~ Worth: $7.12
Take 10 ~ Worth:$2.40 Put 31 ~ Worth: $4.22
Take 13 ~ Worth:$2.49 Put 32 ~ Worth: $4.38
Take 16 ~ Worth:$26.30 Put 33 ~ Worth: $26.00
Take 17 ~ Worth:$8.82 Put 34 ~ Worth: $8.36
Take 22 ~ Worth:$11.81 Put 35 ~ Worth: $17.00
Take 24 ~ Worth:$7.86 Put 36 ~ Worth: $7.88

Seems I may have something f'd up with Take 16...and I couldn't find take 22 if my life depended on it

Will

[craig]

<snipped>.
Take: #3 Padron Executive, $5.87 - Put: #29 La Riqueza No. 2, $7.25(pd)
EGQ Take: #6 Oliva O M Torp, $5.59 - Put: #30 Cabaiguan Guapo RX, $ 7.12
Take: #10 Quintero Breva, $2.40 - Put #31 Cuaba Divinos 2008, $3.81
Take: #13 Por Larrañaga Panatela, $2.49 - Put #32 Punch Petit Punch 2007, $4.00(pd)
Take: #16 Cohiba EL 06 Pyramid, $25.99 - Put #33 God of Fire Carlito Piramide '05, $28.98
Take: #17 Partagás Presidente, $7.05 - Put #34 Vegas Robaina Unicos 2008, $7.60
Take #22 Bolivar Short Bolivar RE A/P, $11.84 - Put #35 Romeo Y Julieta EL 2007, $12.03
Take #24 Bolivar Belicoso Fino, $ 7.86 - Put #36 Cohiba Maduro 5 Secreto 2008, $7.87

Here's my analysis:
Take 3 ~ Worth:$5.87 Put 29 ~ Worth: $8.44
Take 6 ~ Worth:$5.64 Put 30 ~ Worth: $7.12
Take 10 ~ Worth:$2.40 Put 31 ~ Worth: $4.22
Take 13 ~ Worth:$2.49 Put 32 ~ Worth: $4.38
Take 16 ~ Worth:$26.30 Put 33 ~ Worth: $10.40
Take 17 ~ Worth:$8.82 Put 34 ~ Worth: $8.36
Take 22 ~ Worth:$11.81 Put 35 ~ Worth: $17.00
Take 24 ~ Worth:$7.86 Put 36 ~ Worth: $7.88

#16 - I get Rich's price. This EL smokes much more like an EL (doh) than a Cohiba. Vaguely like a 1926 Padron right now, but should continue to improve with age. Enjoyable at three years, probably will be better in a couple more years.

#33 - Fuente rare and HTF are always interesting to value. The GoF 2005 Piramide was issued in 2007. A 300-count Prometheus humidor came with 100 sticks. Four different colours of humidor, ten humidors of each colour, 40 humidors total, 4000 cigars total. MSRP $6500, sold for about a grand less. If we assume the humidor to have a $2500 value, that leaves $3000 of the selling price for the cigars, or $30/stick.

Source: from the first page of a Google search.

#17 - The Presidente used to be the only regular production perfecto outside of Cuaba. The Presidente has the traditional extreme earth Partagas taste, not the mellower version found in the Serie D #4. Again, I get Rich's price.

#34 - Unico I get Will's price.

Comments?

[badwhale]

#16 - I get Rich's price. This EL smokes much more like an EL (doh) than a Cohiba. Vaguely like a 1926 Padron right now, but should continue to improve with age. Enjoyable at three years, probably will be better in a couple more years.

#33 - Fuente rare and HTF are always interesting to value. The GoF 2005 Piramide was issued in 2007. A 300-count Prometheus humidor came with 100 sticks. Four different colours of humidor, ten humidors of each colour, 40 humidors total, 4000 cigars total. MSRP $6500, sold for about a grand less. If we assume the humidor to have a $2500 value, that leaves $3000 of the selling price for the cigars, or $30/stick.

Source: from the first page of a Google search.

#17 - The Presidente used to be the only regular production perfecto outside of Cuaba. The Presidente has the traditional extreme earth Partagas taste, not the mellower version found in the Serie D #4. Again, I get Rich's price.

#34 - Unico I get Will's price.

Comments?

My comment would be, that I didn't update the quantity column in my spreadsheet. I had them as a box of 25 This morning, I'm seeing 2 on Google... 10 ticks at $250 Threrefore, I'm going to edit mine to 26 in the other post.

Will