T.J. I have started a small journal that I write in for every smoke I try, I even go and amend some I have tried previously so I can tell if they aged better or not.
I am pretty new to smoking for real too, but I know I love the Oliva serie O Maduro, and the Camacho Legend-ario, these are some pretty basic, nice flavored smokes IMO.

Also, I have come to realize I am loving the general Robusto size for most all cigars.

Keith