I do read quite a few reviews, (e.g. Cigar Aficionado, Stogie Review, etc) but I also like to check the reviews on this forum. Normally I make a mental note of what I'd like to try, but with a list I see I might not forget. I've never made a list but that is a good idea.
I like Oliva quite a bit, but I want to try the V Series. I have a quite a few Series O Churchills in my humidor, which are quite pleasant. I also have the Master Blend 3, but have not yet smoked it.
I also want to try My Father cigars. I'm also especially interested in their Flor de las Antillas Toro primarily because Cigar Aficionado recently named it #1
Bookmarks