for the comments.

Kenyth, interesting you should note the inconsistency and the oily wrapper. The ones I received were a more medium brown and fairly dull, no sheen.

I'm taking a couple to FLA next week to bounce these off of my buddy and in a couple more weeks after I will smoke the other two and make my "final judgement"!

They do seem like a cigar I would like to keep in the humidor though.