Thank you for the welcome!
All of the cigars in the humidor are oily to the touch, leaving an oily residue on the fingertips. I haven't smoked any of them since I didn't know if this was a bad situation or not. The last smoke I had was September 24, and as I continued to check the humidity level, I noticed them starting to turn oily. I rotated them, and noticed that rotating them hadn't helped. I'll smoke one today so I will be able to answer the other questions you had.

Thanks again.
RetiredMP1SG