Senior Member
Rate cigars you've recently smoked
I decided to start this thread because I think there are a lot of us that try cigars and don't post reviews because we're not so keen on the lingo. (like me) so, just give it a rating of 1- 100.
good cigars I've recently smoked:
Montecristo platinum mini belicoso - 88
Ashton VSG Illusion - 90
Ashton VSG Tres Mystique - 86
Camacho corojo gigante - 89
Junior Member
partagas black classico-85
puros indios piramide #2-87
padron 3000 maduro-88
partagas serie d no.4-88
Senior Member
Cohiba Robusto - my first one, and it was fantastic- 98
Bolivar corona - just finished smoking my first one an hour ago. Knocked me on my ass- 80
Ashon Aged Maduro no. 60 - What a fine smoke it is! - 90
Last edited by Yeagermeister; 03-23-2005 at 09:53 PM.
With glasses high, we raised a cry - freedom had arrived
Former amnesia patient
Oooooooo! Yeager! Cohibas are DEE-LISH!
I must go out and get a few. Haven't had one in a while!
Recent discovery at a famous NH shop
IPO Miami "Torpedo" - 90 nice and sharp!
also... a forgotten treasure
RyJ Churchill "en tubo" (in tube) 95 (actually the whole "tubo" RyJ line is phenominal and proves that you can get a great cigar for $5)
Camacho SLR Toro - 88 - a headkicker - very nice
Gispert Churchill - 80 - really not bad for a $4 cigar!
Rocky Patel Sungrown - 90 - nice, spicy
Senior Member
i just bout a Rocky Patel Sungrown yesterday. probably smoke it tonightOriginally Posted by MMAB
Senior Member
zino platinum shorty - 92
Former amnesia patient
Ok....
Carlos Torano 1959 Silver - Grand Churchill - Excellent cigar - nice body - full flavored and smo-o-o-o-o-th! Tough to find locally at the moment though. Picked a few up while I was in Tampa. Damn! Should of bought a box!
Hey Drake! I just picked up a box of Rocky Patel's SG Toros! Mmmmmmm....mmmmm!!!!!
Member
From this week:
CAO Italia Ciao, dark & spicy, 87
Macanudo Prince Philip Cafe Natural, always smooth, 90
Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur no. 1 Maduro, full bodied & rich, 90
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Churchill Natural, tasty & great draw, 91
flushh
Former amnesia patient
From today.......Sunday, April 10th.....
My best buddy was up visiting from FLA and we had a few RyJ Black Label Anniversario Torpedos. I had forgotten how good they are. That will be my next box purchase!
Former amnesia patient
Ooooops! I didn't "rate" them
Yeah.....I'd give em' a 90. But of course any rating is subjective.
Very smooth, slightly creamy, medium bodied. The classic RyJ "tartness" as I refer to it is mellowed with a little sweetness.
Excellent cigar.
Member
this week's smokes:
Sancho Panza Double Maduro Cervantes - 89
Padron 2000 Maduro - 91
You are what you eat. That's why I'm a fat bastard.
Old School
Bolivar Belicosa- 90
MonteCristo #2-85
Old School
C.A.O. L Anneversery Belicosa- 89
Member
Sancho Panza Double Maduro, Cervantes - 88 - same consistent smoke that could be one of my regulars.
La Gloria Cubana, Wavell Natural - 85 - big disappointment. expected so much more. one dimensional smoke, like slightly bitter espresso. didn't keep me interested at all.
El Rico Habano, Habano Club Natural - 93 - this one definitely made up for the bad LGC. full bodied, with deep flavors and aroma and loads of spices. loved it!
You are what you eat. That's why I'm a fat bastard.
Senior Member
montecristo series v mini belisco - 92
Old School
Partagas short! Man what a good smoke. Very strong! I think it was a bit stronger then the Bolivar Belicosos I've tried. The smoke didn't last that long. Maybe an hour. I guess thats to be expected from a short cigar. But I enjoyed it so much I found myself wanting more at the end:( The draw was excellent through out. Nice and think smoke! I would rate this cigar a 88 out of 100!
Last edited by Roham; 04-20-2005 at 02:45 AM.
Senior Member
oliva 'o' maduro
ole - 80
ovation - 85
very dark wrapper. very mild, i'd say. very smooth, but a bit weak for my taste. but enjoyable nonetheless
Member
Padron 2000 Maduro - 91 - very consistent smoke
La Gloria Cubana Serie R #4 Natural - 92 - full bodied and intense flavors
You are what you eat. That's why I'm a fat bastard.
Corresponding Authority
Another guy with an iron stomach!!! Many people find Oliva "O" Bolds and Maduros STRONG. To me, they seem medium to full.
Here's some ratings of cigars I've smoked recently:
Davidoff Millennium Blend Robusto: 92
Saint Luis Rey Serie A (March, '03): 93
H. Upmann Magnum 46 (December, '04): 91
Cohiba Siglo IV (November, '04): 91
Padron 1926 #9 maduro: 92
Opus X Fuente Fuente: 92
Carlos Torano Exodus 1959 (Gold) Toro: 90
Quintero Brevas (March, '04): 91
Aņejo 48: 90
Punch PC del Punch (July, '04): 91
Quai d'Orsay Gran Corona (May, '04): 92
Ramon Allones Gigantes (June, '01): 91
El Rey del Mundo Choix Supreme (box code unknown): 88
San Cristobal de la Habana La Punta (box code unknown): 92
San Cristobal de la Habana El Principe (October, '03): 92
Ramon Allones Small Club Corona (May, '04): 91
Diamond Crown Maxiumus #5 Robusto: 89
La Aurora 100 Anos Robusto: 87
Zino Platinum Scepter Robusto: 85 (talk about a waste of money)
Greycliff Exresso President maduro: 82 (another over rated cigar, that was terrible)
Troya Corona Club Tubulares (June, '03): 90
Camacho Liberty 2004 Liberty 11/18: 88
Bolivar Coronas Gigantes (June, '98): 89
Hoyo de Monterrey Petit Robustos (August, '04): 89
Member
Arturo Fuente Sungrown Chateau - 94
sweet, complex and flavorful. great short smoke.
La Aurora #4 - 91
like strong espresso, slightly sweet, nutty, cedary
CAO Maduro Corona - 89
typical maduro, one-dimensional, tight draw
El Rey del Mundo Flor de Llaneza - 88
typical Honduran, uninteresting, one-dimensional
You are what you eat. That's why I'm a fat bastard.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks