Me personally, I wouldn't buy, but those cigars aren't my kind of cigars. Some of the more recent reviews online have the cigar as past its prime - the older reviews are glowing, but cigars change. It also depends on storage, and you have to be willing to accept that risk. The ones in coffins would probably carry the least risk, but they're also $200-$250/stick.

OTOH, I have spent more money on more questionable purchases, and $120 isn't a lot in the greater scheme of things. As long as you can have the attitude that you could end up smoking a mere shadow of what the cigar was, and that's cool because life is all about the roads taken, then why not?