I just found (actually was told by a member here) a great cigar bar outside Indianapolis in Brownsburg, Indiana. It is 20 minutes from the airport and worth the drive (if you are travelling). It is called my favorite Cigar and bar www.myfavoritecigar.com

The menu of cigars online does not do it justice. They have a much wider selection then listed. In fact I brought my own cigars because the list of cigars didnt look good at all. The food was excellent and the staff was very cordial. A nice friendly atmosphere.

I wish more bars were like it!