Welcome from NYC Here is my suggestion smoke the Tatuaje and get rid of the Macanudo ( or smoke it to find out what a sucky cigar tastes like ) . Once you have your cooler or humi set up and seasoned go to the newbiew sampler thread here and for $50-$60 you will get a smapler of great cigars that will vary in strength, taste, country of origion etc. When you will smoke those you will in my opinion be a BOTL and have a much better idea for your cigar prefferences