Cusano P1

[King Catfish]

Yes generally you would but you have to understand, as a college kid who currently can only get 16 hrs of work a week, i have tons of time on my hands. I'm actually gonna smoke it tonight and post the rest of the review tomorrow-ish. In hind sight i prolly should have waited but this way i'll get to see if it lives up to what you guys have posted about it. after reading these posts though i am going in with low expectations as i generally don't prefer mild cigars. we'll see though. also it's good to find out to keep it at the higher rh. it was soft enough to where i considered taking it out of the humi for a while to let it dry out. prolly just leave it though.

Of course; I was just poking fun at you a bit.

Nice job on the review, although I think you're being too kind giving this cigar a "B". If I smoked a cigar and the cap exploded it went out twice, I would be hard-pressed to give it more than a D. With those burn and construction issues it would have to taste like a mixture of how a new car and a 19-year-old cheerleader smell for me to give it more than that.

[here'sjohnny]

Of course; I was just poking fun at you a bit.

Nice job on the review, although I think you're being too kind giving this cigar a "B". If I smoked a cigar and the cap exploded it went out twice, I would be hard-pressed to give it more than a D. With those burn and construction issues it would have to taste like a mixture of how a new car and a 19-year-old cheerleader smell for me to give it more than that.

Maybe true, i was being generous b/c both burn issues were fixed with a touch of the lighter. Same goes for it going out, it was an easy relight. The cap thing was just weird, b/c although it exploded, and from time to time i would get a flake, the cut was not the worrst, it looked clean, and the wrapper held strong. I'm also compensating for my newbness, it was a strange smoke and i'll bet it wasn't all the cigars fault.

[King Catfish]

Maybe true, i was being generous b/c both burn issues were fixed with a touch of the lighter. Same goes for it going out, it was an easy relight. The cap thing was just weird, b/c although it exploded, and from time to time i would get a flake, the cut was not the worrst, it looked clean, and the wrapper held strong. I'm also compensating for my newbness, it was a strange smoke and i'll bet it wasn't all the cigars fault.

Of course. I apologize if I came off as questioning your score on this cigar; I would not do that. My previous message did not come off the way I intended. Will you be writing a followup to tell us how the next one turns out?

[here'sjohnny]

Of course. I apologize if I came off as questioning your score on this cigar; I would not do that. My previous message did not come off the way I intended. Will you be writing a followup to tell us how the next one turns out?

Hey no problem KC you are much more experienced than I at this, and i'm fine with criticism, thats part of why i wrote this to compare to what others would score. No need to apologize, i learned early on here that unless there is a f-bomb followed by your username, people here most of the time aren't hating you i appreciate you taking the time to provide some feedback. I'm curious, have you ever smoked this particular cigar?

[King Catfish]

Hey no problem KC you are much more experienced than I at this, and i'm fine with criticism, thats part of why i wrote this to compare to what others would score. No need to apologize, i learned early on here that unless there is a f-bomb followed by your username, people here most of the time aren't hating you i appreciate you taking the time to provide some feedback. I'm curious, have you ever smoked this particular cigar?

"Much" more experienced might be an exaggeration.

No, I have not tried this one. I am waiting for your followup before I try it.