It's easier for me to say which ones I have had, and if I go by the specific vitola, it gets even thinner.

Torano 50th is pretty damn good, however I didn't have the box press. Opus xXx? #3? Meh. I didn't have the Padron 45th natural, but the maduro was a dissapointment to me.

I wasn't overly impressed with the Air Bender everyone raves about.

Casa magna should have been higher, but again, I've not had that vitola.

Prensado's pretty good.

I don't know, I just don't put much stock in CA's ratings, plus to rate something like the VSG Eclipse, just because it's a new vitola for this year, seems lame to me. VSG line, great cigar, stop rating it year after year.

Will