Review These - Reviews

[Maduro Man]

Stick #2

Before
looked to be about 5- 6 inches long, and sun grown as well. Also looked like it was boxed pressed. It smelled ok too.

After
The first half I didn't have any trouble drawling on the stick or keeping it even with the burn. It had a mild taste and smelled really nice. Half way through it became a bit clogged in the middle, and the outer leaf started trying to come off. No big deal though, shortly it was "unclogged" if you will, total smoke time ranging from 30-35 minutes. Also the amount of smoke wasn't too little or two much it was perfect.

Ok...So Bazooka you have a guess on what stick was the more $ one? I dont think you put in your guess yet.

[Bazooka Tooth]

Ok...So Bazooka you have a guess on what stick was the more $ one? I dont think you put in you rguess yet.

I'm gonna have to say the second one. Stick to in my opinion was the more costly cigar.

[Maduro Man]

I'm gonna have to say the second one. Stick to in my opinion was the more costly cigar.

Sorry My brother your guess is wrong! Stick #1 was the more costly stick.

Here is what you smoked...

Stick #1 Cohiba Black. This is a Dominican stick, The binder and the filler have been aged for 3 years. Price $12-$14 per stick

Stick #2 Te-Amo Meditation Maduro. The wrapper, filler and binder are all Mexican. Alot of people put down Mexican smokes but I love em. Price $2-$4 per stick.

Glad you liked em both...

[ashauler]

Review these from WOXOF:
#1
Roughly a toro size stick, RG about 50 or so. Wrapper was medium brown and lighter that stick#2. Construction was good, though looking at the foot and feeling the cigar I could tell it would have a little bit of a loose draw, and after cutting my guess was right. Not "too" loose of a draw but I like a little more resistance.

Light was easy, and the ash held on well. Flavor was good, plenty of smoke. I think I picked up a little bit of leather, maybe some spice. Held up well during the entire smoke. The burn became uneven just past the 1/2 way point and I had to touch it up.

A good smoke, nothing to rave about for me, but certainly not a bad stick.

#2
Roughly the same RG as #1, just about a 1/4" or so longer. Much darker wrapper and very oily.....almost shiny. The roll was tighter that #1, and when cut, the draw had just the right amount of resistance.

Light was easy, and the contrast of the ash against the darkness of the wrapper was very appealing. The flavor on this was very deep, dark, and full. I really enjoyed this cigar, it burned perfectly all the way to the nub. It seemed to open up about the mid point and really produce smoke and a deep sorta coffee/choclatey flavor. MMM-MMM good.

I liked #2 better.....and am going to have to guess it was the more expensive since the construction also appeared to be a tad better than #1.

Thanks again Chris for these two smokes, and their tag-alongs!!

[WOXOF]

Review these from WOXOF:
#1
Roughly a toro size stick, RG about 50 or so. Wrapper was medium brown and lighter that stick#2. Construction was good, though looking at the foot and feeling the cigar I could tell it would have a little bit of a loose draw, and after cutting my guess was right. Not "too" loose of a draw but I like a little more resistance.

Light was easy, and the ash held on well. Flavor was good, plenty of smoke. I think I picked up a little bit of leather, maybe some spice. Held up well during the entire smoke. The burn became uneven just past the 1/2 way point and I had to touch it up.

A good smoke, nothing to rave about for me, but certainly not a bad stick.

#2
Roughly the same RG as #1, just about a 1/4" or so longer. Much darker wrapper and very oily.....almost shiny. The roll was tighter that #1, and when cut, the draw had just the right amount of resistance.

Light was easy, and the contrast of the ash against the darkness of the wrapper was very appealing. The flavor on this was very deep, dark, and full. I really enjoyed this cigar, it burned perfectly all the way to the nub. It seemed to open up about the mid point and really produce smoke and a deep sorta coffee/choclatey flavor. MMM-MMM good.

I liked #2 better.....and am going to have to guess it was the more expensive since the construction also appeared to be a tad better than #1.

Thanks again Chris for these two smokes, and their tag-alongs!!

Great reviews Jamie! I had similar opinions on the two cigars. But your wrong on which was more expensive.

#1 was a Punch Gran Puro. (Paid $4.75 for at the B&M)

#2 was a Cubita SMS Dark Natural. (Paid $1.50 for on Cbid )

[bigwhiteash]

I’ve never written a cigar review, so don’t expect a minute breakdown of flavors, and aromas. But, Here Goes!

CIGAR #1 Provided by ashauler

This cigar is a Torpedo, 6 X 60 (approx), natural wrapper, possibly corojo. Cap is fairly sharp, slightly bumpy, but nicely constructed. Cigar shows a few larger veins, but nothing to detract from an overall well built cigar. Slightly soft to the touch, especially near the foot.

Prelight aroma is a strong sense of something I still can’t put my finger on, but very familiar. Underlying aroma of wood and hay/straw.

Cut with a double guillotine, clean and easy, leading to a draw that is perfect for my tastes, with the sense of hay continuing, and a bit of spice.

I lit this monster with my trusty Bic, which did a fine job, considering the large ring. (due in part to the perfect draw). Immediately got a mild sense of pepper, lots of creamy white smoke. The first 2” were fairly mild to medium, but after that the spice REALLY kicked in, and I found myself puffing a little to frequently. This is right up my alley! Burn is perfect so far, with the ash holding on in concentric rings, very light gray, with a slight yellow cast. Ash finally fell when it reached 2 ½” (right on my shirt). The last 2” picked up a bit more spice, and I finally put it out with about 1 ¼” remaining… I was starting to feel the heat on my fingers and lips. Overall, this was a VERY enjoyable smoking experience, and is going to be difficult to top.

[ashauler]

I’ve never written a cigar review, so don’t expect a minute breakdown of flavors, and aromas. But, Here Goes!

CIGAR #1 Provided by ashauler

This cigar is a Torpedo, 6 X 60 (approx), natural wrapper, possibly corojo. Cap is fairly sharp, slightly bumpy, but nicely constructed. Cigar shows a few larger veins, but nothing to detract from an overall well built cigar. Slightly soft to the touch, especially near the foot.

Prelight aroma is a strong sense of something I still can’t put my finger on, but very familiar. Underlying aroma of wood and hay/straw.

Cut with a double guillotine, clean and easy, leading to a draw that is perfect for my tastes, with the sense of hay continuing, and a bit of spice.

I lit this monster with my trusty Bic, which did a fine job, considering the large ring. (due in part to the perfect draw). Immediately got a mild sense of pepper, lots of creamy white smoke. The first 2” were fairly mild to medium, but after that the spice REALLY kicked in, and I found myself puffing a little to frequently. This is right up my alley! Burn is perfect so far, with the ash holding on in concentric rings, very light gray, with a slight yellow cast. Ash finally fell when it reached 2 ½” (right on my shirt). The last 2” picked up a bit more spice, and I finally put it out with about 1 ¼” remaining… I was starting to feel the heat on my fingers and lips. Overall, this was a VERY enjoyable smoking experience, and is going to be difficult to top.

Nice Review..........looking forward to #2. Glad you enjoyed this smoke, lets hope the next one is enjoyable as well.