I'm not a big LFD of Fuente smoker so I can't help you much with recommendations based on your list, but, it looks like you stick to a very short list of brands. I'd say just branch out and start trying different brands. CAO makes quite a few in that Medium bodied range you seems to enjoy, Padilla does too, Rocky Patel, Torano, etc. I'd say just avoid maduros for a while until you figure out what you like and taste around. I hate to say this knowing your history with your local place, but a good way to start is just to walk into your B&M and ask what they suggest based on what you like.

... actually, have you done the newbie sampler yet? That might be a good way to taste around, jump in that and let the person you're dealing with know what kind of cigars you like.