Top 5 (even top 10 if you have it)

[FunkyCold5]

Wow, it's astonishing the many similar cigars people chose for their list.

Says a lot about that brand!

[Eville]

Not in order:
Montecristo White
RP Sungrown
Cubao 5
Greycliff Crystal LabelTorano Exodus gold
CAO Brazillia Gol!
RyJ No.3
Partegas Coronas Senior

[CAJUNBLAZE]

I would include these:

Any maduro Hemmingways
Any Anejo
Camacho Triple Maduro
CAO MX2
CAO Soprano
Ashton Aged Maduro
Padron 64 Anniv.
Olivia V Maduro
Ashton VSG
Cohiba Black

Rich

[craig]

Wow, it's astonishing the many similar cigars people chose for their list.

Says a lot about that brand!

What I find interesting are the differences in responses to your post on different boards (the ones that I'm on, anyhow ).

With one exception, my top 10 don't meet your availability definition - they're all cigars that I can easily get locally, but you can't . The exception is the Padron Maduro

[basil]

not in any order

San Cristobal
Those 601s, the greens (kill), blue (mm these kill too), black. not as fond of the reds
Perdomo Habano Conn.
Fuente sun grown
LFD dbl ligero - but not the maddies
Padilla 8/11
Ashton VSG enchantment
Fuente Untold Story
Power Ranger but they'd have to be really on sale
Some farmies I'd snap up nearly anytime

[BenjiM]

CX2 by far my favorite
R y J vintage
Padron/ Padron Anniversary
CAO Cameroon
Punch

[WOXOF]

JFR Maddie
Oliva Serie V
CAO Brazilia
601 Green label
Gurkha Ancient Warrior
A.F. King B
VSG (Wouldn't buy the whole box, but definitely stock up)

[daredog4]

Oliva Serie G Maduro
Cohiba Black
RP Vintage 1990
Perdomo Lot 23 Maduro
Perdomo Habano
5 Vegas A
Graycliff 1666
Man O' War (new favorite)

[Roger]

CAO gold
CAP brazillia
A.Fuente gran reserva
Cuesta Rey Camaroon

That's all for me so far due to my inexperience