Hello everyone... First post...

I am getting married soon and I want to get my Groomsmen Humidors and some cigars as their gifts... I think I know what I want to get them; I have it down to 2 humidors. But I would like some input...

Some things to keep in mind:
- All of them are noobs (They have all smoked a cigar from time to time but are by any means experts)
- I want to get them a humidor for under $50.00
- I really don't think they need a big humidor (10-20 cigar) because I would be surprised if they had more than 3 cigars in there at a time.
- I don't want to buy crap, if sub $50 humidors are garbage there isn't really a point, but I am not expecting the best either.


The 2 I am thinking about getting are:
http://www.cheaphumidors.com/Merchan...oduct_Count=31

&

http://www.cheaphumidors.com/Merchan...roduct_Count=0

The only problem I see with the second humidor is, it says it comes with a Humidifier but I do not see it in the picture. Where would it be? would it be an eye sore (because its a glass top) or is it hidden?

And the first humidor is clean and classy but it isn't Spanish Cedar. Does that make a big enough difference?

If you think there is a better humidor I can get on the web for a good price please recommend it, just keep in mind my points above.

I am also wanting to get into cigars so I will be buying myself a humidor too.

Thanks.