Yeah, I kind of agree. Why get noobs nice cigars and a humidor? What if they drop the hobby? Out goes your gift. Go with other "guy" things, like flasks or knives. They're a bit more universal, will be appreciated much on down the road, and you'd be able to get good ones for the cost of cheap humidors and cigars. I got my groomsmen KA-BAR bowie knives, and just had plenty of cigars available at the bachelor party.