No more cigars, is that humor? LOL

[ggiese]

Funny, I found plenty of information very easily. Oh, I know what your problem is...first you have to look somewhere other than FOX.



http://www.brookings.edu/papers/2007...ns_isaacs.aspx

The Pew Charitable Trust and Julia Isaac's report. That sure would be "plenty" of information...

Yep - your'e right - nothing on Fox...

Of course - Nothing on ABC, CBS...

Oh, Look! Nothing on NBC... Strange...

And - most importantly - nothing on CNN either !!!

...as a matter of fact. Aside from a few NPR stations carrying the info, it was nowhere else. Geez... I wonder why???

[Smoked!]

The Pew Charitable Trust and Julia Isaac's report. That sure would be "plenty" of information...

Yep - your'e right - nothing on Fox...

Of course - Nothing on ABC, CBS...

Oh, Look! Nothing on NBC... Strange...

And - most importantly - nothing on CNN either !!!

...as a matter of fact. Aside from a few NPR stations carrying the info, it was nowhere else. Geez... I wonder why???

Gents,
I like this thread. I have no interest in the politics, but you may find some useful and current information on wealth published by those who deal with the wealthy. I suggest researching such sources as Merrill Lynch/Capgemini annual wealth reports (ML is now under the umbrella of Bank of America), Goldman Sachs wealth management division, and possibly Credit Suisse private banking. For starters, a quick google search returned the following: http://www.ml.com/media/79882.pdf

It is difficult to respond to an assertion that most wealthy individuals have inherited their money without first defining wealth. I know a few self-made millionaires. None inherited a significant sum from his family. Not one considers himself "wealthy."

It seems, too, that we tend to restrict our thinking to the sphere in which we travel; specifically, we think in terms of wealth in North America. A great deal of wealth and riches have been created around the globe due to the commodity boom/bust and very inexpensive credit. Just my 0.02.

[ggiese]

I suspect there was not a LOT of research put into his theory about inherited wealth...

Per Forbes (in its dicussion of the worlds 400 richest people):

Two-thirds of the members of The Forbes 400 have fortunes that are entirely self-made, while only 19% of the group inherited their entire fortunes.

Link to the Forbes article

Which leads me back to the original hypothesis put forward by my grandfather (as salty as he was)...

If you strip the wealthy and distribute it evenly - what it took to be a billioniare does not change. The billionaire will use his business saavy and prowess to again become a billionaire - most likely off of the person who does not possess that same skillset. Contrary to what some like Julia Issacs may say - history has repeatedly taught us - it more truly about passion, and much less about "silver spoons"...

[Artyman1200]

Why was I scolded for discussing politics? Is this a privilege for senior members only?

[heftysmokes]

I think a discussion about wealth and how one gets it isn't necessarily a discussion of politics and I'm hopeful those who weigh in won't lead it back that way.


George, I'm pretty sure I read your Grandpa's theory elsewhere but it was attributed to J. Paul Getty.

[ggiese]

I think a discussion about wealth and how one gets it isn't necessarily a discussion of politics and I'm hopeful those who weigh in won't lead it back that way.


George, I'm pretty sure I read your Grandpa's theory elsewhere but it was attributed to J. Paul Getty.

...and here all these years I thought it was that wiley grandpa of mine... It also explains why barry thought it to be an ignorant statement.

Long story, Arty - and I really do not have the time nor inclination to detail it here. Suffice it to say - and you're going to have to trust the community a bit on this - it is best not to discuss politics on this board.

[Artyman1200]

Everyone knows that the creation of wealth comes from reading "Rich Dad, Poor Dad"!

[CoventryCat86]

Why was I scolded for discussing politics? Is this a privilege for senior members only?

They don't allow Democrats in Eastern Tennessee, do they?

[Artyman1200]

They don't allow Democrats in Eastern Tennessee, do they?

They're allowed, they just don't want to be here...there's plenty of ignorance to go around.

[SmokinDVM]

I suspect there was not a LOT of research put into his theory about inherited wealth...

Per Forbes (in its dicussion of the worlds 400 richest people):



Link to the Forbes article

Which leads me back to the original hypothesis put forward by my grandfather (as salty as he was)...

If you strip the wealthy and distribute it evenly - what it took to be a billioniare does not change. The billionaire will use his business saavy and prowess to again become a billionaire - most likely off of the person who does not possess that same skillset. Contrary to what some like Julia Issacs may say - history has repeatedly taught us - it more truly about passion, and much less about "silver spoons"...

Oh yes, the forbes list. You do realize that the only thing that was used to qualify as inherited money was for those people to have gained ALL of it without working for themselves. The vast majority still come from old money, they just have interests of their own also. So, just because someone has a job title, doesn't mean they didn't get it due to their family social status, or that most of their money didn't come directly from inheritance.
Lets use your favorite politician as an example. Old dumbya wouldn't have made 2 cents if it wasn't for his family money and status. He never would have been accepted to ANY major college in the U.S., something about him being a complete idiot.

[ggiese]

Oh yes, the forbes list. You do realize that the only thing that was used to qualify as inherited money was for those people to have gained ALL of it without working for themselves. The vast majority still come from old money, they just have interests of their own also. So, just because someone has a job title, doesn't mean they didn't get it due to their family social status, or that most of their money didn't come directly from inheritance.
Lets use your favorite politician as an example. Old dumbya wouldn't have made 2 cents if it wasn't for his family money and status. He never would have been accepted to ANY major college in the U.S., something about him being a complete idiot.

...I guess you missed the part about "entirely self made".

...and I'm quite sure you have something to support your assertion that Mr. Bush would not have been accepted at ANY major college and had to rely on his family's wealth to survive. A NPR broadcast, no doubt!

Your example is very telling, though - it gets to the heart of a conspiracy I know you would like us to buy into - that our industry leaders - and EVEN the President of the United States are part of the "good ol' boy" welath passed between generations club. If you're not a member - you will not succeed.

Sorry, barry - go back and do your homework. Your "theory" doesn't flesh out. If you read the list of names in the Forbes 400 - there are no doubt a few with inherited wealth, while the majority of billionaires on that list made their money the plain ol' fashioned way - they earned it...

[heftysmokes]

Oh yes, the forbes list. You do realize that the only thing that was used to qualify as inherited money was for those people to have gained ALL of it without working for themselves. The vast majority still come from old money, they just have interests of their own also. So, just because someone has a job title, doesn't mean they didn't get it due to their family social status, or that most of their money didn't come directly from inheritance.
Lets use your favorite politician as an example. Old dumbya wouldn't have made 2 cents if it wasn't for his family money and status. He never would have been accepted to ANY major college in the U.S., something about him being a complete idiot.

You couldn't just make your argument without throwing this in could you? That, and not your political views, is why you're a douchebag.

[ashauler]

Leopards and spots.

[SmokinDVM]

You couldn't just make your argument without throwing this in could you? That, and not your political views, is why you're a douchebag.

those shit-stained fuckers must be knotted up real tight.

[ggiese]

You couldn't just make your argument without throwing this in could you? That, and not your political views, is why you're a douchebag.

[SmokinDVM]

Is that your new avatar gg? I don't know, the guy in that pic is much cooler than you are. You wouldn't want people thinking you were trying to fool them now.