Well I guess I should try for myself and see what I think then. It seemed that the review was a little bit on the harsh side. And yes, I admit not everyone likes or dislikes the same thing. So I guess I could try and see for myself. I think it's just a bit easy to be "influenced" by what people's perceptions are. But thanks for that. And I suppose there might be such a thing as the cigar was too new and not aged enough, or just ended up with a bad gar. Whichever the case, it is unfortunate that he had an awful experience with it. Thanks again. Roger.