After much searching and reading I've come to the conclusion that I must try the following:
Hemmingway
VSG
Montecristo White
Any Padilla
Any Perdomo

Ive tried things like a CAO La Traviata, RP Decade, La Aroma De Cuba, Romeo Y Julieta, Casa Magna, and a Brickhouse with my favorite being a Cohiba Black.

I wasn't a fan of the La Traviata but I never would have known if I didn't try it so I'm always open to new cigars/suggestions.