The best cigar that you smoked in 2011 was ...

[ggiese]

This year has been quite busy, so cigar smoking has been a rare treat. I have been doing my usual go-to's (AF Anejo's, WOAM, Opus X, a few ISOM's, etc.) because I really have not wanted to somke anything I knew I would not enjoy.

The first "new" cigar I've smoked this year was on Tuesday night. I fired ujp a Davidoff Maduro R. I must say - I was blown away. Though - what's not to like? It's well constructed and Helnik Kelner is the most recognized blender in the industry. I knew when I picked it up it would be very likely I would enjoy it. I was not disappointed - a very nice balance of spice (not too much) and flavor.

I'll be smoking those again!

[badwhale]

Best cigar I've smoked this year....Probably a Padron 80th Maduro

Reason: I smoked it around my birthday as a celebration.

Congrats you achieving your goal, Craig!

HNY!
Will

[kevin7]

Toss up between my last Belinda Blue Band Presidente maduro from early 90's and all of the Fuente Mag R Rosados i smoked this year. I know it goes against the grain of the peeps here but I absolutely will not shell out the $ for a Padron above the thousand series. But probably in the top 10 best ever I smoked was a Padron Millennium Maduro

[Devil Doc]

I don't remember, but I'm certain it didn't taste like chocolate.

Doc

[Paddy]

A custom rolled Dominican given to me by- Jamie
I'll take that cigar over Bespoke CC's anyday.

[Roger]

I smoked two that were memorable for this year... LFD toro and a Carlos Torano 1965 both were awesome and I would like to purchase boxes of both sometime in the future.

[CoventryCat86]

Davidoff Double R aged three years. When Jim D thought he was closing the Tobacco Shop in Hartford, he was liquidating some stock and I bought the rest of a CAB. I think I wound up with fifteen or twenty of them. They're a great cigar and they're even better with some age. I only have two left but they all smoked great.