cigar.com doesn't ship to Canada, and discount ketchup doesn't even begin to cover the gulf between a good Havana and a catalogue house brand that claims Cuban aspirations.

For the OP, a good store will know you are a complete newb in under 10 seconds. You'll just be an asshole if you try to sound like you know something.

Given you are in Toronto, just go to Thomas Hinds and buy what they recommend.