First of all, congratulations on finding a girl who enjoys smoking cigars. I'm not good with "novice cigar smoker" advice since I have basically smoked the gas station cheapies and large cigars that may not appeal to most young ladies. I am thoroughly enjoying Ashton Churchills, which I purchased a box of last week. They are very mild and smooth, but they are also very large and aren't exactly cheap. If you think your girl would like a big seven-inch cigar, I think she could handle those.

I'll probably be better able to answer your question in a couple weeks when I try out some cigarillos recommended to me for quick on-campus smoke breaks. Seems like most girls prefer smaller cigars. After I've tried a couple of those brands, I'll give you an update. Good luck with her!