Depends on what flavor you are into. I like some of the ACIDs but others I have found lacking any appeal. They definitely try to match the flavor with the tobacco more than the cheap flavored tins which all have the same blend of tobacco treated with different flavors. I would say try one in a few of the ACID lines (each color band seems to lean towards different ends of the spectrum, as far as botanical vs herbal etc) to see if any of those appeal to you and then check out the rest or try the sampler tin if you like them. I personally like the blue/red/purple lines but the gold I didn't really like at all.

The Kahluah and Java cigars are also made by Drew Estates but not part of the ACID family so they don't have the urban artwork packaging and botanical/herbal flavor.

Some people like the CAO flavored cigars like Eileen's dream.

I can see why people used to smoking quality all tobacco smokes wouldn't be into the ACIDs a lot but a lot of the preference is more because of what they expect out of the cigar is different. Me, I can appreciate either and after trying a few of the cheap tobacco with flavor dumped on it type cigars can appreciate the blending of flavors and selection of tobacco to match it properly which goes into the ACID cigars. Plus since they aren't generally marketing towards your average seasoned smoker they are more willing to experiment with new vitolas and wrappers.