guys, thanks million for the tips thus far. i went to the local Tinder Box to get the owners input before i had even seen all the replies.

At the owners suggestion, i walked out with the following samples..

- St. Luis Rey Reserva Especial
$3.50..... smoked it in the car on the way home
perfect size, not too big. (don't want to torture the non-smokers with a 2 hour cigar!)
nice ash, mild enough .. didn't knock my socks off. price is right.

- Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real
$5.00 ... this was his top suggestion. said its an all around winner

- Olivia Grand Maduro $3.50

- Aiello Nicaragua $3.75

I will take all of your suggestions and sample the smokes i have in hand. keep the advice coming, you guys are great!

ryan