My top 3

[Island Epicurean]

Exodus 1959 Toro
Montecristo #2 (Smoking one right now.)
Romeo Y Julieta Cedros de Luxe #2

These are the 3 that come to mind right now, but I am sure my top 3 will change in about 2 hours.....

[QuietC]

Montecristo classic
C.A.O. Brazilia
and don't really have a third, would need to retry some that I havn't smoked in forever in order to get a good opinion on them.

[Seagar]

I thought the Maximus was a really awesome cigar, however you pay for what you get, its definitely not cheap. After smoking good cigars like this its hard to go back to some more basic commonly known cigars such as Punch, CAO, Partagas, R&J. Dont get me wrong, they all make great cigars but theres sooooo many more out there. Keep this thread up guys.