For you more seasoned smokers, what are the odds that you would be able to identify a cigar by just looking at it, if the band had been taken off?

I'm not so much talking about its taste or smell, but only its appearance. I'm also not talking ablout cigars with unusual or distinctive shapes, but just, let's say, a common Robusto.

The reason I ask is I'm wondering if "blind tastings" of cigars can be truly blind, or do seasoned smokers have a good idea of what they're smoking by just looking at it.

Thanks in advance....