Ok Paul you are pretty tricky. Both cigars are the same length. Both Maduro and both square shaped.

Initial thoughts Cigar #1 looks better, but I like how #2 smells prelight more.

#1 Wrapper is Maduro very nice and smoth to the touch with imbedded slightly visible grains. Very nice smoke: nice tight ash, full flavored yet smooth with lots of creamy smoke. I tasted spices at first then half way through got more leather and nutty tastes with just a bit of coffee towards the end. An awesome 1 and half hour of smoking pleasure

Will post review on #2 tom eve.