Having a Few People over....

[Kenyth]

Since you're buying local and not ordering, it depends mostly on what's available. Non-cigar enthusiasts tend to be impressed by size and a pretty label more than anything else. Smoke shops have plenty of large bundled cheap smokes. Ask the tobacconist for a recommendation and grab whichever one looks the most impressive.

[Jonsey5484]

If you can get Baccarat.....

[Cigar Jack]

I suggested the CASA Torano. The mild cigar by Carlos Torano.

I do agree the rest of the Torano line would be too strong for a novice.