I've always thought it should be at the proprietor's discretion. It seems to be taking away from the right of the owner to decide whether or not he wants smoking in his facility...

However, I have to say it's kind of nice. I don't go out to a lot of bars, but my football team hold their annual Christmas party at a bar. At some weird hour of the night I realized it was actually kind of nice sitting in a bar that isn't full of stale cigarette smoke...

Of course, I would have LOVED to spend the night smoking some of my favorite cigars, but I'll take the sacrifice...

Cigars and pipes yay, cigarettes boo