Alright you guys were right

[bigpoppapuff]

macanudo is overpriced shit...why not just light up an envelope...many of the same flavors.....go buy a baccarat...excellent starter cigar with flavor......

friends don't let friends smoke macanudo's......if i'm giving you advice..you've gotta listen to me...

[ukyfan]

It was a hell of a lot better than the Acid I had before.

[bigpoppapuff]

no question about that...now go get a baccarat.....nice flavor....excellent noob cigar...

[ukyfan]

Well what about Punch? He said that was a good one as well.

[bigpoppapuff]

punch is a fuller-flavored cigar than a macanudo.....macs are from the D.R.....punch from honduras,as are baccarat. i'm actually surprised that the guy would suggest both...when one is envelope mild and the other is fuller.

i'll be very surprised if you don't enjoy the baccarat.

[prophetic_joe]

I enjoy Punch quite a bit, excellent everyday smoke and a very well priced cigar. They taste much better than the mac which isn't a terrible smoke, however considering that you'll pay at least $6 per mac and can get Punch for between $2.50 and $4.00 it shows how overpriced they are. If you have the option try a Punch Rare Corojo and try some Maduro wrapped cigars as well you'll find they have a nice smooth flavor. Good move leaving the flavored Acids, if the tabacco is good you don't need to add flavoring.

[nhcigarfan]

Also consider trying sancho panza dbl mad, and ex. Frt. both are great smokes, far better than the Macs and at least half the price.

[reaganyouth84]

I enjoy Punch quite a bit, excellent everyday smoke and a very well priced cigar. They taste much better than the mac which isn't a terrible smoke, however considering that you'll pay at least $6 per mac and can get Punch for between $2.50 and $4.00 it shows how overpriced they are. If you have the option try a Punch Rare Corojo and try some Maduro wrapped cigars as well you'll find they have a nice smooth flavor. Good move leaving the flavored Acids, if the tabacco is good you don't need to add flavoring.

I agree with Joe's suggestion with the Punch Rare Corojo. They are pretty good smokes for the price. I think the Hemingway Short Story is a pretty good fairly mild smoke for around 4 bucks.

-Mike

[ukyfan]

I enjoy Punch quite a bit, excellent everyday smoke and a very well priced cigar. They taste much better than the mac which isn't a terrible smoke, however considering that you'll pay at least $6 per mac and can get Punch for between $2.50 and $4.00 it shows how overpriced they are. If you have the option try a Punch Rare Corojo and try some Maduro wrapped cigars as well you'll find they have a nice smooth flavor. Good move leaving the flavored Acids, if the tabacco is good you don't need to add flavoring.

The mac was like $5.25 and the Punch was $4 I think. Now as I was looking around in there they had some cigar that was in its own wooden box for like $30 a piece . I didn't get the name of it, but there were others of the same brand there with it. I don't see how I could ever pay that much for *one* cigar! Well if I had Bill Gates type money I would prob try it.

[CoventryCat86]

Now now, I'd say ukyfan is taking a step in the right direction so let's not be so hard on him.

However ukyfan, bigpoppa has an excellent suggestion for a mild cigar so see if your local guy has any of those for you to try. I can guarantee you that you will enjoy those much more than a Macanudo