I like the format that slc used.

For my everyday smokes:
5 Vegas Double Corona
Padron 2000
Black Peral Rojo Toro
Carlos Torano Exodus 1959 Toro

One step up each week:
Oliva "O" Bold Omni or Ovation or Ole
CAO Brazilia Lambada or any other
AF Best Seller, Chateau Fuente (Regular and Sun Grown)
RyJ Clemenceau Tubos
5 Vegas Limitida '05

I try to have something a little nicer once a week:
Ashton Sun Grown (Any of these lovelies will do, currently, my favorite cigar line)
AF Anejo Anything (only had one so far)
Ashton Aged Maduro #40 (Toro Sized) (only had one so far)
Opus X (only had one so far)
La Aurora Preferidos (only had one so far)

In between all that, I have a few other things in my humidor waiting to get smoked when the odd mood hits me:

Trilogy "Old-School" Authentic Corojo (Did I mention that I currently love anything corojo?)
Sancho Panza
LGC Wavells

Well, that's my entire smoking platform! You can find any of the above cigars in my humidor at any time.