SFG75 the "Master Passer" NOT!!!

[CoventryCat86]

BTW-In the end, it's Randy's call since he's the pass host. If he thinks I screwed him, he'll say so. Don't be so pretentious as to pretend to speak for him. I'll talk to him later tonight as he returns from Omaha. If he wants me to replace an unintentionally damaged cigar that I pad $20.55 for, then I gladly do that. What do you think of that Bill?

I think an Ashton Cabinet #3 would cover a La Uncia cameroon Torp#1. I'll ask him tonight, no-I'll insist that he take it and you can go on your tardy watchdog ways.

You paid over $20.00 for a $14.00 cigar? You are a fool.

I also think you KNOW Randy well enough that he would NEVER say "Yeah Scott, I think you SHOULD do something about that damaged stick" because Randy, having the heart of gold that he does, would never say that. Hell, I'd probably never say that ot my brother in law either because why start a family feud over a goddam cigar?

What makes me sick here is that you KNOW Randy would never say anything and I think you are taking advantage of him.

Here'e the RIGHT way to handle the situation (but of course an arrogant know-it-all like you would never think of this):

You should buy a nice cigar or two and go to Randy and say "Gee, I see that the Ashton VSG Spellbound I put in your pass was damaged. I've got a couple of replacement sticks for you, an Opus X Double Corona and a Padron 1926 #1 maduro. I hope this begins to make up for the ruined cigar I put in your pass."

That would have been the way many of us here would have handled the situation Scotty, but no, you see nothing wrong with your proposed solution which is to put Randy on the spot in an uncomfortable position that you know he has no choice in.

You make me sick to my stomach.