Don Kiki Browns and Sancho Panza Double Maduro. You can get boxes for under $40. Definately my top choice for go to smokes. The Punch London Club, like ashauler said, is a good smoke.

Try the Famous Buenos Maduritos. Link These come out to be about .75 a stick and are an excellent smoke for the price.

You can get Indian Tubac on CigarBid.com for pretty cheap, even though I'm not a big fan it seems alot of people are. I do like the Cameroon Legend.

Try a Nestor maduro, too.