I try and read a lot of blind cigar reviews for this very reason. A couple on my list to try are:

Maria Mancini Magic Mountain
Gurkha Legend
Don Tomas Special Edition Corojo Maduro
La Gloria Wavell Madoro

One every day cigar I liked is the Primo Del Rey Maduro which was suggested to me by my local B&M. I plan on picking up 5-10 more for a poker game next week.

Hope this helps.
-Chad