Quote Originally Posted by cigarsarge View Post
Ditto..My exact thoughts. If Bill is brought back..What about Sid...What about Manix...What about Corona Gigante?

Think about it. Banning decisions should be final.

Members feelings about Bill aside, where was his banning poll? I must have missed that.

Sid got one.

Manix is the reason we have them.

csmokers banning policy is as follows

Banning Policy
Since this is a member moderated community I wish to lay down ground rules for the banning of a user.
  • PM sent to Admin. Admin will review.
  • If Admin deems the situation to be a banable offence then a poll will be created in the Politics forum.
  • The poll options will be as follows:
    • Permanent ban
    • 7 day suspension (some situations may warrant 30 days)
    • No ban
  • A 51% majority must rule in favor of the ban.
  • At least 10 senior members must vote in the poll for results to be valid.
  • The poll will be open for voting for 24 hours.


When the policy is followed, I agree with Ken that the decision should be final. However, the policy was not followed in Bill's case.

Also, Corona Gigante is not banned, just run off. He can come back anytime he chooses.