most disappointing smoke?

[Diesel Grinch]

I was in a taste test this summer and I would have to say Black Patch cigars.

DG

[nhcigarfan]

Not sure if one stands out but I am generally disappointed in maduro wrappers. Some are great but alot are just plain boring.

[ashauler]

I'd have to say the CAO Italia....I really wanted to like that smoke and just couldn't do it.

[CigarDoc]

I'd have to say the CAO Italia....I really wanted to like that smoke and just couldn't do it.

I have found this smoke to be either you love it or hate it... I'm on the love it side

[chefchris]

I'd have to say the CAO Italia....I really wanted to like that smoke and just couldn't do it.

ah, don't tell me that. i've been looking forward to trying it.

I'm gonna go with Partagas Serie P I had a couple weeks ago. Terrible burn, no flavor, but I know it wasn't fake. I don't know what the deal was.

[derivation]

For me, it was a red dot cohiba. I picked a few up when I first got into cigars, and because of the name and the price I was expecting a lot. The first and every one after made me feel like I was smoking a $2 cigar, not something 10+.

[guado]

Partagas 160, CAO cameroon(disgustiing), Perdomo Cabinet reserve Cameroon(ugh),

CAO italia....it was good, then ok, then ugh, then ok, then kinda ok/good all in one stick. Not fighting for another one anytime soon but if someone gives me one I wouldn't turn it down.

[basil]

I agree with derivation on the red dots - they suck. Very disappointed in the ERdM Supremo oscuro. The shorter ones are ok though. I like the padron 1000 series, but only 2K and 3K. The larger ones taste like charcoal past the 1/2-way point to me.