Im a bit of a newb too but the ones i have liked so far:

5 Vegas Gold (a light 'gar, the bouquet is awesome, almost honey notes?)
Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 (this cigar is just a great smoke)
Gurkha Nepalese Warrior (very robust complex)
A. Fuente Hemmingway (very beginner gar)
Romeo Y julieta 1875 Aniversario Maduro (very spicy)
CAO - Italia (a sweet smoke nice notes)
Rocky Patel Old World Reserve Maduro
A. Fuente Opus X (super creamy cigar but overpriced)
Gurkha G3 Rare Estate Blend Mini Torpedos ( i loved these)


THose have been my memorables..

I mean you will straigt off find things you hate and things you love... so what i did was when i went to buy cigars i would try and get as crazy of a mixed bag as I could and i was able to narrrow down what I like...