I almost always have something to drink with my cigar. My usual is a glass of Bourbon or Scotch, but sometimes I have a Mt. Dew. There is a thread on here somewhere just about drinking soda with your cigar.

I don't normally pay attention to ratings. These are given by people who (hopefully) have way more experience than me. I put more stake in word of mouth from friends and the BOTLs here.

Honestly, if someone puts hints of leather and nuts in a review, it doesn't sway my desire to try that stick. If they say, "This cigar was so awesome I nubbed it. You have to try one!" then I'll probably go for it.

As far as your experience with the 5 Vegas, I am the same way. I enjoy all of the 5 Vegas offerings except for the Gold.

spiffy