My cigars go from firm to soft all the time...I think its mostly the oil from good humi seasoning ('I think' being the key phrase...) As long as it tastes well I wouldn't think it would be a problem humi-wise....

BTW, from the selections you've tried so far it seems that you dig the med-bodied types...I'd suggest something by Punch, RyJ, Sancho Panza, or a CAO Cameroon....all of those are also pretty cheap so it won't hurt your wallet to buy a stick to try...I'd also recommend a Helix for their cheapness, but nobody here seems to love em'....

Again, I'm a rookie just like you so take my suggestions with a grain of salt