Mega Review Signup and Voting

**Cyris** · 02-19-2010, 07:34 PM

Originally Posted by EdgeMan

I am in.

If we are to vote on the listed cigars I will put a vote in for the RP Olde World reserve and the Graycliff to be mega-reviewed. I have never tasted a 5 vegas that I liked so far so my opinion is to scratch that one and choose another inexpensive cigar but that is just me.

Overall, very cool idea... Thanks for volunteering buzz.

Ok, My votes: ( same as Buzz except for NO. [5] )

[1] Graycliff Double Expresso (~$12/stick)
[1] Rocky Patel Old World Reserve (~$8/stick)
[1] Cubao Maduro (~$7/stick)
[1] Cain Maduro (~$6/stick)
[1] Padron 3000 (not sure of the box price atm)

Donald

I like their Maduros.. the classics are good too, of the ones I have tasted. I am with you on the Padron 3000, always wanted to try one of those. I personally really like the RP line (including the one listed)... but since you are a huge Edge fan, maybe that would be a good one to mass review? I know I enjoyed it, and many others here have. Its in the same price range as the Cinco Classics I believe.

**EdgeMan** · 02-19-2010, 07:53 PM

Yeah, that sounds good. I say my number five is and edge maduro (toro or misille).
And you are correct. They are in the 4.50 - 5.00 range.

Originally Posted by Cyris

I like their Maduros.. the classics are good too, of the ones I have tasted. I am with you on the Padron 3000, always wanted to try one of those. I personally really like the RP line (including the one listed)... but since you are a huge Edge fan, maybe that would be a good one to mass review? I know I enjoyed it, and many others here have. Its in the same price range as the Cinco Classics I believe.

**mail man** · 02-19-2010, 07:59 PM

I wouldn't mind jumping in on this, but not really sure how the finances are going to be, so I might have to sit the first one out.
Also, I will only play if Buzz doesn't make fun of my sigtag

Keith

**buzz** · 02-19-2010, 08:06 PM

Originally Posted by mail man

I wouldn't mind jumping in on this, but not really sure how the finances are going to be, so I might have to sit the first one out.
Also, I will only play if Buzz doesn't make fun of my sigtag

Keith

Why would I make fun of it?

After we decide which cigar or cigars we are going to review you can decide how many cigars you want to buy/review.

So, what would you vote for?

-Buzz

**mail man** · 02-20-2010, 08:30 PM

Originally Posted by buzz

Why would I make fun of it?

After we decide which cigar or cigars we are going to review you can decide how many cigars you want to buy/review.

So, what would you vote for?

-Buzz

I know you are jealous of my portriat, so I wanted to make sure you didn't make fun of it.

As for my pics, I would love any of the ones mentioned, are the Cains the ones made by Oliva, and if so, that would be my first pick, as for my own input, I wouldn't mind anything form the DPG line, or the Ashton VSG.

**Mangyrat** · 02-20-2010, 08:39 PM

If you have room for one more I would like to give it a try.

The line up you submitted is fine with me.

Graycliff Double Expresso
Rocky Patel Old World Reserve
Cubao Maduro
Cain Habano
5 Vegas Series 'A'
Padron 3000
Rocky Patel Edge Missile Maduro

**Roger** · 02-21-2010, 03:13 AM

Cain habano
Ghurkha dragon
Padron 3000
Rocky patel edge
Cao brazillia

I hope I can swing the finaces on this first one, perhaps with a trade. Roger.

**kevin7** · 02-19-2010, 08:06 PM

http://www.cigarnexus.com/mott/index.html

Way old,older than some of you young uns LOL. Its a nice review format and a nice stroll down memory lane for me

**buzz** · 02-19-2010, 08:12 PM

Originally Posted by kevin7

http://www.cigarnexus.com/mott/index.html

Way old,older than some of you young uns LOL. Its a nice review format and a nice stroll down memory lane for me

Nice, I will be stealing, I mean referencing, that site for sure. Thanks Kevin - so will you be participating? I know you dig you some Perdomos...

-Buzz