Quote Originally Posted by EdgeMan View Post
I am in.

If we are to vote on the listed cigars I will put a vote in for the RP Olde World reserve and the Graycliff to be mega-reviewed. I have never tasted a 5 vegas that I liked so far so my opinion is to scratch that one and choose another inexpensive cigar but that is just me.

Overall, very cool idea... Thanks for volunteering buzz.

Ok, My votes: ( same as Buzz except for NO. [5] )

[1] Graycliff Double Expresso (~$12/stick)
[1] Rocky Patel Old World Reserve (~$8/stick)
[1] Cubao Maduro (~$7/stick)
[1] Cain Maduro (~$6/stick)
[1] Padron 3000 (not sure of the box price atm)

Donald
I like their Maduros.. the classics are good too, of the ones I have tasted. I am with you on the Padron 3000, always wanted to try one of those. I personally really like the RP line (including the one listed)... but since you are a huge Edge fan, maybe that would be a good one to mass review? I know I enjoyed it, and many others here have. Its in the same price range as the Cinco Classics I believe.