MEGA Review IV Signup

[buzz]

Post up the dang Emily reviews you lazy bum!

Oh, wait.

[craig]

Post up the dang Emily reviews you lazy bum!

Oh, wait.

Just tell us what the cigar was, at least.

[badwhale]

I heard it's Acid

[craig]

I heard it's Acid

Nah. I'm thinking Camacho.

[buzz]

Okie dokie folks... MR4 is a wrap. That was a ton of fun and extremely interesting with the blind element IMHO. Thanks for participating guys!

Amanda (My Father #5 Toro): http://www.cigarsmokers.com/threads/...-Father-5-Toro)
Betty (Joya de Nicaragua Fuerte Serie B Robusto): http://www.cigarsmokers.com/threads/...erie-B-Robusto)
Carolyn (Cubao Maduro #5): http://www.cigarsmokers.com/threads/...o-Maduro-No.-5)
Dawn (Davidoff Millennium Robusto): http://www.cigarsmokers.com/threads/...ennium-Robusto)
Emily (Punch Gran Puro Libertad): http://www.cigarsmokers.com/threads/...-Puro-Libertad)

[buzz]

And here is what we paid:
My Father = $169.99 / 23 = $7.39/stick
JdN = $45.50 / 20 = $2.28
Cubao = $85.05 / 20 = $4.25/stick
Davidoff = $422.75 / 25 = $16.91/stick
Punch = $57.36 / 20 = $2.87/stick

Add $5 shipping and you should arrive at the price that you paid in the first post of this thread. If I screwed up the math somewhere let me know and ashauler will pay the difference.


Here is what each "option" had (green cells indicate 2 of that cigar):

[badwhale]

Great job Buzz. I don't know about anyone else, but I've been following these like a series playoff:

Amanda (My Father #5 Toro)

amanda is the girl you might take to the back seat of your 1992 chevy cavalier and then never tell your friends about. I only selected maybe for "smoke again" because, unfortunately, "poison" had two amanda's in it. I think that buzz is actually trying to poison me.

Betty (Joya de Nicaragua Fuerte Serie B Robusto)

betty's the kind of girl that makes you get to know her before you can do the deed. All that talking is not worth it in this case. The lady was densely filled with tobacco. She felt a little heavy in the hand. I couldn't say that i really liked this cigar. It was ok, at least it wasn't a bad cigar. She redeemed herself in the final 3rd a little.

Carolyn (Cubao Maduro #5)

i would take this girl out to a steak dinner.

Dawn (Davidoff Millennium Robusto)

"mom, this is dawn." i'm convinced that this is an oliva serie v. However i don't think that this particular vitola is made in the v family. Unless my ring gauge meter is way off. But i'll price it as such anyway.

Emily (Punch Gran Puro Libertad)

"emily, it's not you. It's me. I just want to be friends." (but i'll never call you again.) this lady started out very good, but after a short while became what i'm not looking for.

ETA: Also, I'm not sure to what level Ashauler helped out the deciding process, but Thanks Jamie for smackin' Buzzard around during the process. He needs it at that level.