bigwhiteash / mrtr33 Reviews

[bigwhiteash]

Nice review Dennis!! I won this set in SLCRaiders contest at X-mas........don't have the 'nads to actually smoke them though.

That monster box they came in was taking up too much valuable real estate

mrtr has the other half (Italia), should be up soon

[mrtr33]

I did a little research before smoking this cigar. That is my occupation, I can't help it. According to the CAO website, the filler contains a leaf grown in the Benevento region of Italy, coincidentally, where my ancestors hail from.

I also read another passage where the veep of CAO International that stated the original ring gauge was slated to be a 137 - but was impossible to light.

Enough banter. On to smoking.



The construction was pretty good. Lighter than the Brazilia, with a light oily sheen on the outside, this cigar is firm to the touch, but not rock hard. The cap was really big, and the draw was a nice medium in pull. The cigar is a nice weight in hand, about what you would expect.



It's about right here where the flavor starts. I, too, was expecting burn issues, yet this cigar burned very evenly for me. Not a whole lot of smoke, and I am not the best to comment on flavors I experience, but it had a very good, unique tobacco taste. A slight amount of spice, but nothing overwhelming. Very nice earthy tobacco flavors, however.



The volume of smoke begins to increase about here. Something else I thought was a bit odd was the color of the ash. It almost looks like the foot was dipped in something, noting it's color. The rest of the ash was relatively white, the ash firm enough to survive my juvenile "bouncing up and down" and "swaying side to side" tests.



Honestly, I didn't even know ash this long was possible. It broke off a few puffs after this. Smoke volume continuing to increase, as with the flavor. I didn't detect bitterness, the flavors seemed to intensify. I did not notice the cigar getting hotter as it approached the end.



The ash broke, and I actually had to set it down, rather than tapping it off. From here, the burn on the cigar went a little off, and some of the wrapper was even coming apart. Honestly, by the time I got to this point, at almost 2 hours, I was done.

The aftertaste was nice. No harshness experienced at all, although I had quite the nicotine rush. Quite a pleasant cigar.

Much thanks to bigwhiteash for the experience.

[BDurrani]

Nice reviews guys, might have to try one of each.

[King Catfish]

Nice review. More, please! This is great.

[DeeDubya]

I'd seen a pic of one of these with a complete ash. I think the smoker had to hold it upright while smoking for the last inch or two. Anyway, the ash held until the end. Crazy, couldn't imagine that thing falling in my eye.

[mrtr33]

This cigar is one half of the "Toast Across America 2007", held by the Cigar Family Charitable Foundation commemorative set. The only difference I can tell between this DC Maximum #2 and the one I can purchase at my local B&M is a cedar sleeve and additional bands denoting the foundation event.



A dark, oily Ecuadorian sun-grown wrapper adorns this cigar. The construction is almost flawless, a slight glitch undetectable to the eye without removing the wrapper, but ended up not affecting the experience. The cigar is very firm, and slightly heavy in weight. It's actually very intimidating. The cap wasn't very big, but not too small. Having temporarily misplaced my pocketknife, I decided to use it with my cheap cutter. The draw was medium - not too tight, but not too loose, either. I sat down for a game of chess and watching the sunset with my fiancee and a glass of Mad River Brewing Company Jamaica Brand Red Ale, and toasted the foot.



It's about here where the full-flavor kicks in. This cigar has been described as both a full-bodied and a med/full bodied cigar, and I would tend to classify it with the latter description. Loads of white, creamy smoke. A spiciness that is noticeable, but not overpowering. An underlying taste of cedar predominates everything. There is a slight sweetness that I can detect as well, but very subtle.



It's about here where the strength and flavor mellow out a bit. Which is a good thing for me. Still tons of smoke, and the cigar is still holding together firmly. The ash is very white, and very reasonably firm still.



Right here at the very end, a little bit of the wrapper came apart. Not to worry - after an hour and a half, I was pretty much nearing my end. While the cigar was still firm, it was getting slightly warm about 10 minutes after this, and just a tad bitter. I decided to end this on a high note, and put it down. The sun was gone, the beer had been enjoyed, and I had checkmated my fiancees king.

Thanks again to bigwhiteash for such an enjoyable experience. I went into this cigar with no expectations, as I had a Diamond Crown #4 (non-Maximus), and didn't really enjoy it. Thanks for this experience to turn me around on these.

[bigwhiteash]

Nice Job my Friend

Glad you enjoyed the smoke

Dennis~